WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner
1 - 12 of 12 Posts

mathu

· Registered
Joined
·
502 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
I always wanted a GS and this year finally decided to get a 9F. However there is no way to see one in person so I have spent weeks looking at all the available reviews and pics and still cannot decide.

SBGX261 - an obvous choice of course and I really like the size (my wrist is 6.25 and there are hardly any well made watches with a bracelet in sub 40mm range on the market that are not in DJ price territory) and overall proportions (better than the 40mm non-GMT models). However watching every single YT review and seeing hundreds of real life photos I feel like the finishing on the bigger models is actually better? Especially the indices look rather flat and rounded on 37mm model and price difference between 37mm and 40mm is marginal. As for the black vs champagne I settled for black because I am afraid of the champagne dial looking like a cheap gold watch in certain lighting.

SBGP011/013 - these two look more premium than 26x but then I am a bit afraid of the size. I wear 40mm watches all the time but most of them on a strap (my wrist is flat and I easily wear full size Black Bay on a fitted rubber strap) and while I have worn Seiko Sumo on a bracelet for many years, I would not like to end up with a dress watch that wears like a diver. I compared the stock pics of Sumo vs SBGP in 1:1 scale and it seems like the end links on both have similar span (lug to lug says nothing about how the bracelet would wrap around the wrist). So my concern is that I would end up with oversized dress watch. And while the details of SBGP are better than on SBGX, the overall proportions look odd, like there was something missing on the dial.

SBGN003/005 - they seem to be most praised 9F GS model and would check all the boxes (39mm, very well made) however they do not seem to look like a Grand Seiko to me, I just do not like the use of lume and the watch looks too sporty for what I am looking for. THey are also hardest to get because of the high demand.

SBGN011/013 - these models look like top of the line for 9F, the finishing is absoutely stunning (I am not sure if they do something magical to the indices and hands but all the vids and photos look way better than SBGP line). I especially like the combination of champagne dial and blued GMT hand on 011 - it looks almost as good as the Snowflake, absolutely stunning. But then they are not only 40mm but also rather thick, comparable to my Damasko DA36 which wears good as a modern flieger on a strap but would not look good on a bracelet. However I am considering getting one of these and wear them on a special occasions only (as opposed to SBGX which would be my daily wear). Still I am not sure if it is worth to pay that price for a quartz as it gets really close to spring drive territory (but anything other than 9F might be very problematic when it comes to servicing in Europe).

What would you guys suggest here? It is really tough to decide without seeing one in person. Is the SBGN really superior compared to the cheaper models?

Now for the actual ordeing of the watch: I would not like to spend more than 2500 EUR and I want the watch that is perfect (the second hand must hit the indices perfectly and with no dust or other imperfections on the dial). So this is where it gets tricky in Europe.

There is only one AD in my country and rather far away so ordering online is the only option. They seem to have SBGN013 in stock but the price is full MSRP (3000 EUR) - way over my budget. They might order SBGP line for me but the price would be 2750 EUR and I doubt any discounts would be possible as they do not have it in stock right now. It is the safest option though for any returns. By the way they say that SBGX line is not available anymore and I suspect that GS is pulling it out from European market.

Jura Watches - the prices seem more reasonable (and it is still an AD) as they offer 10% discount code and that would be my choice pre-Brexit, however in this new situation I am afraid of what would happen if I had to send the watch back to the UK - it gets very complicated due to VAT and customs. Also Jura does not seem to get best reviews when it comes to ordering from them.

Montredo - as a grey dealer they offer really good prices and they seem to offer manufacturer warranty but the selection of models is limited and obviously they would not inspect the watch for me as it would come from a random AD somewhere in Europe. But the store is Germany based so within the EU.

Watches of Mayfair - broader selection, same prices, but they issue their own warranty and are UK based - anything goes wrong and I have to export the watch back to UK.

Of course most of the grey dealers trade on Chrono24 so I might end up getting the watch over there with their buyers protection.

Higuchi - that is the last option and it might be the best as he might inspect the watch for me, pricing seems to be somewhere between grey dealers and AD but then it is a domestic Japanese warranty and obviously ordering from Japan is way more risky than ordering from Europe if I ever had to return it.

So which option would you suggest? How did you get your GS if you live in EU? I would appreciate all the tips and suggestions.
 
If you are EU based then I would wait till after lockdown and travel to the AD to get some wrist time and compare models in the metal.

It is an expensive purchase so worth taking the time and effort to get the right one for you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: captious
I have cycled through my fair share of GS 9fs and I would suggest getting a 44gs case sbgv model or if you prefer the sbgx size, jump up a bit more and get a sbgv with a similar case. I love the all brushed bracelet on my sbgv223 actually (the sbgv225 I used to own is still the best blue dial I have ever owned). The sbgx models lack an indice at 3 o'clock (painted on) and for whatever reason that has always annoyed me. As for dial, I never thought I would suggest this, but champagne. I actually hate champagne dials, but the GS champagne is mindblowing. It requires a 12 step process to produce it and it is incredibly dynamic. It has to be one of the most beautiful dials I have ever owned.

I have never owned a 9F GMT, so I don't have a lot of input. I have tried them on and they're great...but if I was going to sell my sbgv205 the only thing I would sell it for would be one of the anti-magnetic GSs. Again, it goes back to the incredibly unique case design. Another model to think about :)

sbgv205 44gs case, champagne dial
15694177


sbgv223
15694180


sbgv225
15694183
 
Discussion starter · #6 ·
If you are EU based then I would wait till after lockdown and travel to the AD to get some wrist time and compare models in the metal.

It is an expensive purchase so worth taking the time and effort to get the right one for you.
Unfortunately there is no way to compare against SGBX as they are out of stock.

I have cycled through my fair share of GS 9fs and I would suggest getting a 44gs case sbgv model or if you prefer the sbgx size, jump up a bit more and get a sbgv with a similar case. I love the all brushed bracelet on my sbgv223 actually (the sbgv225 I used to own is still the best blue dial I have ever owned). The sbgx models lack an indice at 3 o'clock (painted on) and for whatever reason that has always annoyed me. As for dial, I never thought I would suggest this, but champagne. I actually hate champagne dials, but the GS champagne is mindblowing. It requires a 12 step process to produce it and it is incredibly dynamic. It has to be one of the most beautiful dials I have ever owned.
Yes the 44GS is very nice, however for the same price I would prefer this beauty:

15694501


It is THE best looking 9F in my opinion. And here is what I mean by different level of finishing of these 40mm:

15694514


Everything is just razor sharp. There is an additional bevel on each hand's tip so that there are no round surfaces anywhere. This is how the Snowflake is finished. I think it applies to non-GMT version as well. SBGX looks crude in comparison:

15694536


And I like how the champagne hands and indices in 40mm are all polished vs brushed in 37mm. That's why I am hesitating as the price difference between SBGX and others is not that substantial compared to how much better 40mm looks. I would get 37mm if I had not seen the difference but it is definitely there.
 
I purchased my Grand Seiko GMT from Jura watches, here in the UK. I couldn't fault them. (y)
15694806
 
  • Like
Reactions: PiguetPolo and O .
Unfortunately there is no way to compare against SGBX as they are out of stock.

Yes the 44GS is very nice, however for the same price I would prefer this beauty:

View attachment 15694501

It is THE best looking 9F in my opinion. And here is what I mean by different level of finishing of these 40mm:

View attachment 15694514

Everything is just razor sharp. There is an additional bevel on each hand's tip so that there are no round surfaces anywhere. This is how the Snowflake is finished. I think it applies to non-GMT version as well. SBGX looks crude in comparison:

View attachment 15694536

And I like how the champagne hands and indices in 40mm are all polished vs brushed in 37mm. That's why I am hesitating as the price difference between SBGX and others is not that substantial compared to how much better 40mm looks. I would get 37mm if I had not seen the difference but it is definitely there.
It is the same level of finish on the sbgv223/225 indices and handset as far as I can tell and yes I have handled them.
15695540


Either way, that GMT is gorgeous! It sounds like you are leaning that way, so jump on it while you can.
 
Discussion starter · #9 ·
OK I ruled out the basic 40mm models and I am leaning heavily toward the SBGX261 despite being less refined. I went through many Instagram photos of all these watches and realized that only SBGX261 has perfect proportions because apparently when they scaled up the dial on other models, they kept the same thickness of the hands and in result they look thin. It looks better on the GMT models because the dial is very busy and has additional GMT hand. Basic 40mm look oversized. SBGX just looks perfect and even better on a nice strap.

Can you tell me how these 40mm GMTs wear in terms of weight and comfort? Google says 150 grams which is in dive watches territory. Can you wear them for 9-10 hrs straight especially on a smaller wrists? If not then I will get the 37mm and be happy with it.
 
I can only help with part of your question, which relates to Jura. I’m based in the UK and on the several occasions I’ve purchased from them (including one GS), they’ve been excellent - very easy to get hold of by email and on the phone, and good at advising on options on the phone.

Returning a watch (not the GS!) was very easy with Jura too.

That said, I get what you’re saying about Brexit making everything more complicated now.
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts