[GP7742]

Definitely the TAG. I think it's got some modern-cool going on and the black dial looks outstanding. Just consider the micro-adjust thing.

Tudor hasn't impressed me, frankly. I find myself disappointed with their offerings.

 

[mattw84]

I generally love Tudor watches and there are some Tags I like, but I don’t love either of these. If you’re dead set on one or the other, I’d opt for the Tag in this case.

 

[zztopops]

While personal preferences vary when it comes to watches, it may be worth considering other options that better align with your individual taste and style.

With a wide range of designs and brands to choose from, it might be worth exploring other options before making a final decision.

Ultimately, the most important thing is to choose a watch that you feel confident and comfortable wearing and has a remotest sense of appeal amongst your fellow WUSers.

 

[cleger]

Get the Tag.

 

[Pedronev85]

Defo the Tag... I know the brand doesn't get much love on here or most other forums but I've owned a fair few Tags and can honestly say I've loved them all! This Carrera is stunning as well so don't think you'd be disappointed 😊

 

[Baka1969]

I prefer the Tudor.

 

[one8armory]

Tag all the way, if you are only considering looks/how it makes you feel. Price, desirability, resell are all considerations of course, which would likely favor the Tudor. But if you're keeping this for a while for enjoyment, then go with what you like better. For me, that's the Tag.

 

[debussychopin]

That tag looks like the older WAR prefix model with the longer lugs and more simple case cut design and less visible chapter ring. I was so tempted to get this white dial one you pictured, as I have the blue one in 41mm and it one of my prettiest watches.

The design got less refined with the WBN model which comes w a less sleek bracelet, shorter lugs, and a strange conspicuous chapter ring. The whole design looks off if you really look at it.

I'd go w the tag if it is the older model, but go with the tudor if it is the newer tag.

 

[bigclive2011]

Neither are really my cup of tea, but the Tag at a push.

 

[wolverine303]

Personally, I would go with the Tudor. But given your circumstances, if you have in mind to diversify your collection, go for the TAG. You already have 2 Tudors 😅. But at the end of the day, both are great looking watches, great history, versatile and comfortable. Most important thing to keep in mind, enjoy wearing it after you buy it, doesn't matter which one it is. Good luck and have fun! 🙋‍♂️

 

[bneath]

That Tag bracelet gap at the lugs looks large but the Tudor dial is both unattractive and harder to read at a glance.

 

[PaulB73]

Tudor will hold its value better and as a rule I prefer the brand to tag. But from those two choices, I like the tag more.

 

[ffritz]

Tag Carrera, no contest. The Tudor just looks outdated in comparison.

 

[jacob's_Time]

I saw a tag recently and thought the lugs were too long. Also I thought the bracelet had too many things going on with the fat and skinny center Link

 

[JustWatchMe925]

I do love the Carrera, but Tudor gets my vote...my fiance has a BB32 with silver dial, it's surprisingly legible and looks fantastic when the light catches the sunray dial

 

[jacob's_Time]

BAUME & MERCIER 65697

I love this watch. It's silver not white. There is one in used and probably needs service condition on the big auction site ( not my listing)

 

[bth1234]

Of those two I prefer the Tag. The Tudor looks a bit too rounded for me.

 

[OneEyeMan]

Easy decision for me.
Any watch that has to print "Rotor Self-Winding" on its
face is comical to me.
That's an automatic NO from me.
Besides, the TAG is much better looking!

 

[ChronoTraveler]

Tag easily. I had the black GMT version and it was a great watch. Can easily recommend.

 

[maxmfs]

Between the two, I’d pick the Tudor. To me, the design seems cleaner and timeless, whereas the TAG seems busier and might rapidly appear dated.