[jcpeel]

I have both. It’s simply an amazing watch. I’ve tried different straps on both. I always end up favoring whichever one is on the bracelet at the time.

I am going to part ways with one of them to help fund a 3861 sapphire sandwich moonwatch. I’ll probably get a black Seamaster 300 too. (Love the lollipop second hand that’s on the latest iteration, like the Spectre edition). Those are both black watches, so maybe keep the blue?

I am torn! Help!

(I am also trying to get my post count up so I can participate in the for sale forum)

 

[Jeff4134]

Keep both and get a Pelagos LHD.

 

[cwr]

Blue.

 

[King_Neptune]

Always black.

 

[Johnjr]

Rolex = Black
Tudor = Blue

 

[SSMOKE]

I REALLY like my blue Pelagos!! The colors of Pelagos blue and titanium look SPECTACULAR together, IMO. That being typed, it gets the least amount of time in my rotation. Mostly, because I rarely wear blue and like to match. For you, ultimately having two black OMEGAS, a blue Pelagos is the obvious answer. Like me, you may wear it the least, while at the same time, be SUPER GLAD that you have it.

 

[bes-b2]

Blue Pelagos is the keeper, IMO

 

[PeteJ]

Real divers only ever choose technical black!

 

[griffon89]

View attachment 16706654 View attachment 16706654 View attachment 16706655
I REALLY like my blue Pelagos!! The colors of Pelagos blue and titanium look SPECTACULAR together, IMO. That being typed, it gets the least amount of time in my rotation. Mostly, because I rarely wear blue and like to match. For you, ultimately having two black OMEGAS, a blue Pelagos is the obvious answer. Like me, you may wear it the least, while at the same time, be SUPER GLAD that you have it.

That’s a really great collection of dive watches right there!

 

[labguy]

Blue. Nothing unique to me at least about Black. I like the vibrancy of Blue.

 

[Tony A.H]

if the majority of your time pieces are black?. then a Blue dial for a change is good.
but if you have several watches in your collection. i personally favor Black over different dial color . Black is classic and timeless. you don't get tired of it.
BTW. love the 3861 . every serious collector should have this watch.

 

[Dan Pierce]

Blue for me.
dP

 

[SunnyH]

Another vote for the blue!

 

[thetimecollective]

If it's a Pelagos, it should be blue. Had a black one but sold it due to that very reason.

 

[rjich]

I had both but found black lhd was easier fit with my wardrobe. The blue was very pretty though. I sold one in here and all went smoothly

 

[joeuk]

If you going for a speedy then go with blue as the speedy is a black dial so why not have a different colour

 

[usccopeland]

The same dial color on all my watches would get boring. That and the blue on the Pelagos is nice looking.

 

[PeteJ]

if the majority of your time pieces are black?. then a Blue dial for a change is good.
but if you have several watches in your collection. i personally favor Black over different dial color . Black is classic and timeless. you don't get tired of it.
BTW. love the 3861 . every serious collector should have this watch.

Unless they don’t like it?

In which case they spend the money on something they do?

 

[Rozebol]

Pelagos in black is one of my favorite dials. Blue looks great too… but black dial is the choice here!

 

[Orive 8]

I've never been of fan of blue dials, so I would keep the black one.

Good luck with your decision.