I absolutely love the look of that superocean. ive almost bought it countless times im just scared of the lug to lug. im not crazy about titanium watches and although Tudor makes a beautiful watch, I am little tired of looking at the pelagos and the BB58 for the time being. im a fan of what breitling is doing in general although I wish they hadn't changed the super ocean to the new design. the new navitimers and top times are gorgeous.

TLR - The Superocean!

 

Agree 100%. Tudor has made some really good looking and affordable watches lately, but the result is that they are everywhere.

I think the Breitling is more interesting and it fits like a glove. It’s also cheaper, so…..

 

Superocean gets my vote even at equal value. Love the older style.

 

I’d pick the Superocean because:

1. thinner
2. stainless steel
3. numerals
4. I already have a Tudor with those hands

 

Superocean!!!

 

Superocean, size is better. Pelagos wears too chunky.

 

Tudor for me. It’s

 

Pelagos every day then twice on Sunday.

 

Lol. Great replies. Thanks!

 

For me, personally, Breitling. It has more of it's own identity and I like the look of it better besides. However, whichever one speaks to you the most. You have to be the one smiling when you look down at your wrist. Best of luck with whatever you choose.

 

I have the SO 44mm and it's fantastic, as well as dead on accurate. It's built like a tank. The AR on that watch is second to none too.

Sent from my Pixel 6 using Tapatalk

 

Superocean for lotsa the reasons already mentioned here. If you don’t want it, please PM me the boutique’s info…

 

im in this battle right now lol, my guy has two super ocean's a 42mm and a 44mm in blue plus the pelagos, really torn in which was to go

 

Superocean gets my vote. Nearly pulled the trigger numerous times. Either way you won’t be disappointed.

 

If actions speak louder than words, the SuperOcean gets my vote. Mine keeps great time and looks good on a variety of straps. Although I don’t like the clasp all that much, the bracelet is terrific. It’s currently on this shark strap.

The Pelagius case is just too thick/chunkyfor me.

 

I love my so. I might get a Pelagos some day, but today, I wear my SO quite a bit and have zero regrets that I bought it.

 

I love em both but I think I would go with the superocean here. That dial is just sick.

Sent from my Pixel 5 using Tapatalk

 

Really like the Super Ocean 3-6-9 dial.

 

I have the Pelagos but I think that Breitling is also prettty cool. I don't think I am being contraversial in saying the the Pelagos is a superor watch no matter which way you look at it but the Breitling looks great.

 

If push came to shove I'd choose the breitling, even with those Comic Sans numerals, because it's got a lot more going for it visually than the Tudor does. To me, the Pelagos looks like a Pagani Design homage of a Tudor (and yeah I know that doesn't make sense, but it's just what I see), so it'd be a hard pass for me.

 

I bought a Pagani Design Black Bay GMT homage. Had the DG3804 Pearl movement, before they started using the Seiko NH34.
It was more accurate than my Tudor GMT S&G that I paid 40 times more for. It was actually a fairly well-made watch. Spot on to the second for over two weeks, with a deviation of no more than + or -5 s at any time. How long they last is anyone's guess. I have another Pagani homage with the same movement, sometimes it's feeling accurate, sometimes it's off by 5 minutes.

 

Glad to see Breitling still getting love. This would come down to coin toss for me. I can’t tell which I’d choose.

 

Both are great Watches. If you had the chance to buy the First Gen. Tudor Pelagos, new, that would be my choice. But with your choices given Breitling SO is cheaper to buy, plus would have a harder time to find a new one in that model and color dial again. The Newer model Tudor Pelagos, is a miss with the lines of text on the dial for me anyway. Vance.

 

Every time I hear Breitling I remember a poll on TZ in the early 2000's.
Which watch has given you the most trouble and needed the most repairs?
90% vote for Breitling. Hahaha

 

There are a few folk here who think that what once applied decades ago still applies today. Like waistlines (not).

Superocean for me too, although I'd actually take the previous gen model. In fact, I did! It's bombproof. ETA 2824-2, easy to service, great lume, 1,500m WR, robust dive extension. Smaller than the Pelagos, too, which may be technically the more advanced watch here... but I think Sinn does "chunky" better.

 

Blue Pelagos, maybe, but between these two the Superocean for sure.

 

I have an even older version of the Superocean and love it, so Breitling is my choice.

 

My opinion would be they are very different watches, the pelagos for me is a weekend watch tool watch its quite brutal I have the lhd version, its all titanium so its very specific colour - the superocean is more if a do it all watch its slimmer and has more of an everyday appeal to it. I have tried them on and really liked it.

 

The SO is a more wearable watch from a size and aesthetics standpoint. The bracelet on the P has a quick adjust clasp but it is not as thin and comfortable as the SO. I compared these two watches and bought the SO (I decided on the white dial).