WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner

Do you ever rub oil into your leather strap? Is there a "best" product to use?

1 reading
19K views 39 replies 22 participants last post by  austinwft  
#1 ·
I rubbed some good quality olive oil into the back side of my Helm leather strap.
...foolishly not realizing that it would go through the holes to the front side.
So, I then had to rub some oil everywhere, and now the "tobacco" brown color is
a somewhat darker brown, but still nice.

I wanted to protect the watch against getting wet when I wash my hands,
and I wanted to make the back side more supple and soft...and so it wouldn't crack.
----
What is the RIGHT way for the future??
Do you ever do this for any of your leather straps?
And is there any problem with what I did?
And lastly, is there any way to retain the same color
(and have it not get darker)?

Thanks, everyone. Of course, I should have asked BEFORE I did this,
but better late than never.
 
Save
#3 ·
@noregrets Thanks. The picture of the leather strap next to the small jar of cream
is a very light tan brown, so that should mean that it doesn't darken the strap
more than a bit.
Is there a problem with what I did with the olive oil?
 
Save
#5 · (Edited)
I don't own any leather strap and haven't tried it, but if I had to try something, I'd use a shoe grease like that. I use it on my boots.

16104137


It provides waterproofing on boots and treats leather quite well. It's colorless, but it surely darkens the leather over time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: watchman600
Save
#6 ·
Here are some pictures of the Helm Tobacco leather...that is now somewhat darker
(though it is NOT a big deal...and still looks good), because I for some reason decided to rub good quality olive oil into it all over. I want to know the correct/proper way to treat and protect the leather straps for the future
(in a way that won't change or darken their color).
Reaching out...some people must have experience and knowledge in this area:
16104190
16104192
16104196
16104200
16104202

Thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mediocre
Save
#8 ·
I have used Smith's Leather Balm for years with excellent results. It is true that especially with light brown / tan straps, some darkening will occur, however, I noticed that the amount that is applied makes a big difference.

If I use an old rag and gently apply a thin layer until the strap looks uniform, the color will go back to almost original after the leather has absorbed the product (a few hours). I do this every couple of months or when I feel the leather is too dry.

When I first used the product, I rubbed it in with my thumb and used a very generous amount. As a result, the leather got tacky and darkened quite a bit (and mostly stayed that way for a long time). With a lighter application, not so much or not at all.

As far as olive oil goes, I have no personal experience but I think there's nothing wrong with it. Might be hard to use just a small amount though.

16104220
 
#10 ·
I’ve used oils/creams made for protecting leather shoes. Note, however, that they may not only darken the leather, but may also affect the color/hue of the stitching (especially white). I’ve also sprayed straps with the “waterproofing” spray that can be found at shoe stores and many other places. How well does it work? I’ve never really tested it, but the straps are still in pretty good shape after over a year.
 
#12 · (Edited)
I noticed I had a white substance on a leather strap,. I think it must have brushed against some mayonnaise while eating, and the strap must have then absorbed the oil, which darkened the leather, and left a white mayo residue on the strap, which wiped off. Over time the strap has now faded back to the original colour, pretty much.

(Slightly edited to improve readability)
 
#13 ·
Yeah, I'm not gonna use olive oil.... Ever.

If you're not worried about darkening and prefer an oil to a balm, try neatsfoot oil. I use it on my work boots after I've cleaned the leather to keep em in good shape. I've used it on one strap that was incredibly tough and dry with great results.

16104477


I've heard Mink Oil is another good option, though I've never tried it.
 
#17 ·
I highly recommend Chamberlains Leather Milk. If you want oil, use "Formula#3".

I recommend it because unlike typical shoe conditioners this stuff is safe for your skin. There's a big difference between conditioning leather with something that'll never contact your skin vs. a watch strap.

I originally tried it because Saddle Back Leather recommended it, and its basically replaced all of the other leather care products I used to use.

I agree with dfwcowboy regarding olive oil. If you use it too much it could start to make your strap smell really bad (rancid). Same goes for coconut, vegetable oil, or anything else from your pantry ??
 
Save
#24 ·
Saphir is also what I use on my shell cordovan strap because that is what German at Casa Fagliano recommended I use when I told him my new strap arrived looking a little “dried out” to me. In hindsight it was probably an overreaction on my part.
 
#25 ·
This article says that vaseline may be good to use
(I intuitively thought about vaseline and will likely try that next time.
I think it will probably work and be far better than the olive oil I tried):
HOW TO SOFTEN YOUR LEATHER GOODS
From boots and belts to shoes and saddles, there's an entire world of products that benefit from leather's durability and strength. While these goods look great when you first get them home from the store, there's often a breaking-in period before they reach their full comfort levels. You might want to make this time go by quickly, but it's important to do it properly to avoid compromising the beauty and integrity of your product. Before you haphazardly apply a generic leather softener to your items, here are some professional suggestions on how to correctly condition them.

Before you start the process of softening your leather shoes or other items, you should first make sure the items are ready to receive the chosen product. This is true no matter which softening method you plan to use. Start by thoroughly cleaning every surface you intend to treat with conditioner. This can be done with a clean cloth and a small amount of water, but there are also cleaners available to help deal with tougher jobs. Once you're finished removing stains and dirt, let the piece dry completely for up to 24 hours at room temperature.

Petroleum Jelly and Rubbing Alcohol

The second method for softening leather is the application of rubbing alcohol and petroleum jelly. Start by using a cotton ball to apply the alcohol to every surface you'd like to soften. This might take a few different treatments because of alcohol's tendency to evaporate quickly. Once you've completely treated the whole item, follow up with a generous layer of petroleum jelly using your fingers as an applicator. Unlike the coconut oil method, you shouldn't experience any significant darkening of your items when you're finished.

Commercial Products

Home remedies are a good place to start, but there are occasions when they don't do the job completely. If you need something stronger, head to your local store and find a commercial product that's appropriate for your item. Read the product's instructions and apply according to the manufacturer's recommendations. You might have to reapply a few times every year to prevent your leather goods from drying out.

Proper Care After Softening

Once you've softened your leather goods to a desirable level, it's important to exercise proper care to keep them strong and beautiful for long-term use. You've invested a lot in your items, so treat them well by keeping a few things in mind:

  • Avoid prolonged exposure to direct sunlight during storage.
  • Allow good air flow by never storing items in sealed plastic bags.
  • Prevent stains by regularly using a damp cloth to clean your goods.
  • When polishing or conditioning, use products that don't contain dyes.
  • Always test any new conditioners or cleaners on a small area before full application.

Does Vaseline soften leather? Yes, petroleum jelly does help with softening leather as well. This works on wallets, bags, shoes, and even watch straps. The Vaseline helps coat and soften the leather to prevent cracking.
 
Save
#26 ·
IMO, Some of these recommendations depend on how your leather was tanned. The more expensive and quality method is vegetable tanned leather. The cheaper/quicker method is a chemical process called chrome tanned. Most if not all quality watch straps are made with veg. tanned leather.

The basic goal of conditioning veg.tanned leather is to replace the fats, oils, and waxes that were lost from the leather after the tanning process from use. Petroleum products don’t do that.

Rather than applying DIY stuff like baby oil or Vaseline, use conditioners that replace what was lost during the tanning process. If you doubt my explanation, contact the website where your leather came from and ask their suggestion, for example Horween. I can almost guarantee they won’t recommend using petroleum based products. Sure it might put a shine on the leather, but in the long run it’s not good for the leather.

Petroleum products affect chrome tanned leather much less, if at all since its so stuffed with mostly synthetic chemicals.
 
Save
#27 ·
@Jiman That's a good point I didn't think of.
What is your recommendation?
This article shows a few that were mentioned by others here:
Bicks #4
Leather Honey
Chamberlain's Leather Milk #3
I appreciate the help...and want to protect the leather straps,
so that they stay looking great,
soften them up a little, and not have to worry about getting them wet
when I wash my hands or go out in the rain. Thanks
 
Save
#28 ·
I mentioned Chamberlain earlier. I listed #3 because you specified oil, but they offer a cream and cleaner as well (#1, #2 respectively). I have lots of leather stuff from Saddleback, Whites Boots, shell cordovan jackets, and various leather watch straps from various makers. I like that Chamberlains is safe for your skin, yet at the same time yields great results. Apparently you can even drink it….yuk.

IME, oil based conditioners will naturally darken leather, especially on natural/uncolored leather. Creams on the other hand wont always darken. If you want a more water resistant leather, the oil is suggested.

If you really want to go all out, you can melt pure bees wax with a hair dryer or heat gun onto the strap and buff to a shine. It’s a process called hot stuffing leather. Sort of the leather version of waxed canvas. It works great to make hard use boots (no synthetic liners) waterproof. EDIT: On second thought, don’t do that to your leather strap 😀
 
  • Like
Reactions: watchman600
Save
#29 · (Edited)
As someone that works with leather as a hobby(not watch straps) I can recommend a couple of products.

For veg tanned leathers I would use obenaufs leather oil or their heavy duty LP conditioner.

Also Saphir Super Invulner for water proofing or Saphir grease/dubbin for general conditioning and element protection.

For chrome tanned leathers or mix tannage leathers I would recommend Horween’s Venetian Cream. If you have expensive shell Cordovan or Chromexcel straps this is the best stuff for it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
#30 ·
I think that I am going to get this one:
---
Hopefully, on my reddish-brown leather strap from Helm called "whiskey"
it will not significantly darken it / make it less attractive.


---
I also hope that I can use it on my black Cordovan leather strap from Christopher Ward.
The deployment clasp is digging into the underside of the leather and making a mark,
and I just want to protect the beautiful leather so that it stays looking beautiful.
---
And I have a Direnzo leather strap that I would use it on:
 
Save
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.