Thanks!
Thanks for checking out the review, and you're right, this brand has built quite a following! But I think that did not come easily, and was a result of nearly a decade of work in the space. The watch community wasn't as welcoming to microbrands back then as it is today, so Halios and the few others at the time earned their laurels the old fashioned way - through good products.
I've seen a few Seaforths with misaligned markers on this forum (I went through all 600 pages of the Seaforth thread before recently buying 3 Seaforths), but I've also seen plenty that looked alright. I'm very picky about stuff like that, and I didn't find any issues with the markers on this watch. And so is the original owner of this watch (Mike Razak - The Time Bum / Watch Clicker / Two Broke Watch Snobs - Login • Instagram). I'll go out on a limb and assume that the misaligned markers in the Seaforth thread were eventually fixed by Halios. Because if they didn't, there would be a paper trail of complaints on the Seaforth thread for sure. And there isn't.
I've handled 4 Halios watches so far (3 Seaforths and 1 Fairwind), and yes the brushing on the case isn't exceptional, but it is on par with the top 90% of microbrands in the category, and I say that with experience. After my journey through countless microbrand watch reviews, very few microbrands have managed to pique my own curiosity and check off my own personal set of boxes - build quality, design, dial finishing and value. Halios, Christopher Ward and Formex are my top three contenders there, and I've already put my own money into Halios and Formex.
So I respectfully disagree, and I think they're accurately rated. And I honestly believe that there is a majority of truth behind the fan fare. But don't take my word for it, I'm a newly converted Halios fanboy!