WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner

Hamilton Murph 38 - An Explorer for the rest of us?*

12465 Views 77 Replies 53 Participants Last post by  Zany4
*Despite the click bait-y title, this post is not comparing the Murph to the Explorer.

A few impressions after wearing the Murph every day for 2 weeks. The watch wears very well. Its dimensions (38 x 44.7 x 11.1) should appeal to a wide variety of wrist sizes. It has often been compared to the Seiko Alpinist line, but the shorter lug-to-lug (44.7 vs. 46.5) and especially the thinner profile (11.1 vs. 13.2) make the watch extremely wearable. My wrist is only 6.25" and it fits perfectly with no lug overhang, and it slides under long sleeves without a problem.

The dial and hands are beautiful. This is subjective, but I love the slightly Art Deco numerals and cathedral hands. I wouldn't call the numeral color fauxtina, it is closer to bronze or khaki. Against the black face it presents a refined look. I've had no problems reading the watch. Some people have bemoaned the lack of Morse code on the seconds hand, but I think it improves the watch and allows it to stand on its own.

I read in other reviews that the stock strap was not good, and unfortunately that turned out to be true. I immediately replaced it with a brown leather strap from ColaReb (it's their Firenze line). I think it matches the vibe of the watch. I'm not convinced that it will look good on a bracelet, so I am considering a variety of options for summer including cork, silicone, and single-pass NATO.

The movement (H-10 caliber) is keeping incredible time. It's only gained about 2 seconds the entire time I have owned it. I've only had one other watch keep better time. It has an 80-hour power reserve so I could leave it for the weekend without having to reset it.

Yes, this is the watch from Interstellar but made smaller. I've never seen the movie, so that's neither here nor there for me. I just see a very classy looking field-style watch.

While definitely not a Rolex Explorer, there are similarities - black dial, time only, field-ish watch that is appropriate in a wide variety of situations. It has the same vibe: elegant but rugged. Like the Explorer, it could be your one watch. And you will save yourself roughly $9K.
Watch Analog watch Clock Font Rectangle
See less See more
  • Like
  • Love
  • Helpful
Reactions: 5
41 - 60 of 78 Posts
The main reason I have not considered a Murph, is the non-screw down crown. Vance.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
So what do you “screw down” people believe a screw down crown does? Because I think you may be overestimating its intended functionality (and missing out on some great watches because of it).

Either way, Hamilton says 100m WR, which should be more than good enough for a field watch.
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Nice overview, @Stelwick. If I purchased a Hammy, this would be it.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I have three Khaki Field watches and am a fan of the 38mm Murph.

Watch Analog watch White Light Silver


One of my issues is the premium Hamilton prices the Murph over the other 38mm Khaki autos. Can I justify getting the Murph with the black Khaki already in my collection? That's difficult to say. Also, as already stated, I'd like to have a bracelet option. I swap straps often and would like to be able to wear a bracelet with the Murph on occasion.

Although I know in some ways I would prefer the Murph to my current black auto, I'm not sure if I should buy one at its price.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 4
2
Hamilton Khaki Murph 38 is in my wishlist. I like it too. No date, vintage style, good readability, good size for my wrist. Perfect. But the price is too high for me, and I'm afraid of a possible contradiction with my Khaki Field 40. Murph can push it into the background.
Watch Analog watch Light Clock Watch accessory

Appreciate the thoughtful review. I encourage you to see Intersteller—a fun movie (with outstanding music) that you’d enjoy all the more with this awesome watch on your wrist!
Yes, watch the Interstellar, and Hamilton Khaki Pilot will be your next watch. :)

See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Hamilton Khaki Murph 38 is in my wishlist. I like it too. No date, vintage style, good readability, good size for my wrist. Perfect. But the price is too high for me, and I'm afraid of a possible contradiction with my Khaki Field 40. Murph can push it into the background.
View attachment 17178808


Yes, watch the Interstellar, and Hamilton Khaki Pilot will be your next watch. :)
Too bad that watch shown isn't the one McConaughey wears in the film lol
Too bad that watch shown isn't the one McConaughey wears in the film lol
I wouldn't buy that one.
Too bad that watch shown isn't the one McConaughey wears in the film lol
Ups! 🙊 Sorry.
You are right. This was my mistake, I didn't look carefully at that watch. Fixed it.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
It's a great looking watch but the price is kind of hard to swallow when you can get a khaki field for significantly less. If I were to buy one I'd only do it if I got a great deal on it.
It's a great looking watch but the price is kind of hard to swallow when you can get a khaki field for significantly less. If I were to buy one I'd only do it if I got a great deal on it.
People keep saying this, but I was happy to pay extra for a case with appropriate length lugs, cathedral hands, and cool looking numerals.
  • Like
  • Helpful
Reactions: 4
I have three Khaki Field watches and am a fan of the 38mm Murph.

View attachment 17178758

One of my issues is the premium Hamilton prices the Murph over the other 38mm Khaki autos. Can I justify getting the Murph with the black Khaki already in my collection? That's difficult to say. Also, as already stated, I'd like to have a bracelet option. I swap straps often and would like to be able to wear a bracelet with the Murph on occasion.

Although I know in some ways I would prefer the Murph to my current black auto, I'm not sure if I should buy one at its price.
Doesn't the bracelet you have on your silver Khaki fit the new Murph? I thought the Murph and 38mm Khaki autos had the same case but maybe I'm wrong.
Doesn't the bracelet you have on your silver Khaki fit the new Murph? I thought the Murph and 38mm Khaki autos had the same case but maybe I'm wrong.
I'm not 100% certain. If it does, even better. Sometimes, in pictures, the lugs on the Murph 38mm seem shorter than the 38mm autos I have.

IMHO if they priced the Murph between where it is now and the price of the 38mm auto, it would be perfect for me and I'd already have it in my collection. As it stands, I just don't see getting one.
I'm not 100% certain. If it does, even better. Sometimes, in pictures, the lugs on the Murph 38mm seem shorter than the 38mm autos I have.

IMHO if they priced the Murph between where it is now and the price of the 38mm auto, it would be perfect for me and I'd already have it in my collection. As it stands, I just don't see getting one.
The lugs on the Murph 38 are 44.7; on the Auto they are 47. Further up this thread there is a model number of a Hamilton bracelet that fits the Murph38, at least according to someone on Reddit.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
The lugs on the Murph 38 are 44.7; on the Auto they are 47. Further up this thread there is a model number of a Hamilton bracelet that fits the Murph38, at least according to someone on Reddit.
Darn it! lol

At least my eyes aren't deceiving me.
2
I've tried a couple KFM, and the L2L just kills it for me. Have not tried the KFA, but on paper, would assume the same?

The 38mm Murph? Probably just right.

Reminds me of a previous model Glycine, the Combat 6 36mm with Arabic indexes.

Watch Analog watch White Light Product


This was a sweet watch, and the Murph hits all the right design cues, in comparison. The hands killed the Glycine for me, and the Murph does a better job, with the cathedral hands.

Used to be, no-date would have killed the Murph for me, but I've come around on that. In person, it is a really sweet looking thing.

However, as much as I like it... one can only have so many, and a Sinn 656 fills the role better on my end.

Watch Analog watch Silver Clock Watch accessory


Who knows... maybe someday I'll try one out, but where I might have been in line for one first day of release... not in a hurry to pick one up.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I just can't do cathedral hands :confused:.
They grow on you. I didn’t like them until I got an alpinist.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
This Hammy is a nice Watch. It is not as Dressy in my opinion, not as versatile as the Rolex Explorer. Maybe it’s because of the Brackets between the Two? Hard to beat the Rolex 3135, movement. Vance.
That looks great, better than the Alpinist and your strap choice is spot on.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Doesn't this have the disposable Powermatic 80 movement with the plastic escapement?
Doesn't this have the disposable Powermatic 80 movement with the plastic escapement?
It's the caliber H-10 with silicone mainspring. What's your point? Aren't most movements inherently disposable and replaceable?
41 - 60 of 78 Posts
Top