Not that I am who this watch was marketed to, but I'm near that demographic in my overall desires regarding watches. I'm glad to see the diameter is moving in the right direction but believe it could still be two to three millimeters smaller. Hodinkee/Tag knew they were going sell the limited offering out in minutes, so why cater to the "bigger is better" crowd with a classic offering? With regard to height, I'm wholly unimpressed. A manual movement in these re-issues (also thinking about the artfully executed but not quite perfected Longines Heritage re-issues) would benefit wearability in a considerable way as well contribute to their charm as homage pieces.
Overall, I think Tag/Hodinkee did a decent job and am aware there are wholes in my opinion/argument. Again, my personal belief is that they (the market) is moving in the correct direction.