WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner

Just received the Mido Ocean Star 200. I absolutely LOVE the watch, but am worried about the AR coating and bezel scratching if used as a beater

1 reading
6.5K views 43 replies 34 participants last post by  Gebbeth  
#1 ·
So after some QC difficulties with Seiko, I decided to go in a different direction. Found that insane deal on a Mido Ocean Star 200 Black, and pulled the trigger. I think it was exactly $500 shipped to my door.

Was hesitant about it, thinking maybe I'd end up returning it and trying again for another Seiko.

But the watch arrived today, and holy hell. I legitimately don't understand how this is a $500 watch. It just feels so.........EXPENSIVE. The wood box, leather liner, packaging, etc. is close to what you'd find on an IWC or an Omega. The watch itself..............people always say how watches "are comparable to watches costing 3x as much!" But in this case, I think that statement is actually true. The watch is rock solid, and it just FEELS expensive. From my initial look, everything lines up - date wheels, bezel, etc. The crystal, bracelet, bezel..............it just looks and feels like a $5000 watch. It feels much more substantial than many Omegas I've handled, and worlds better than the Seiko King Turtle. It inspires confidence that it is well-built. I'll post a review later on once I've had a chance to mess with it a bit.

HERE'S MY QUESTION:

The watch has a double-coating antireflective crystal - which I LOVE. I love the way the light plays off of it and the way it makes the dial look inky black. Likewise, it has a beautiful aluminum bezel insert.

But I bought this watch to take over "beater" duties from my Seiko Black Monster SKX779K1. Daily wear, in pools, at the beach, at bars, occasionally while sleeping, etc.

So the questions are:

1. How good is Mido's AR coating in terms of not looking banged up and having SOME degree of scratch resistance? In my experience, I have an IWC 3777-10 that I believe has external AR coating, and I haven't been able to find a single blemish in it after a few years of wear. I also have a Farer Stanhope, which I think might also have an external AR coating, but not sure. Either way, not a single blemish there either. But I do have a Raymond Weil Parsifal, that has scratches in the outer edge of the AR, which I believe were caused by me rubbing a heavily starched shirt sleeve against it to remove smudges.

2. How do aluminum bezels typically show wear? I'm sure they obviously scratch more easily than ceramic or steel bezels (like my Seiko Monster). What are your thoughts on this? Is this just a nice "patina" effect that collects memories?


Will post a full review of the watch once I have a chance, along with photographs.
 
#2 ·
I came to the thread hoping for pic and was disappointed :cry:

To your point on the Mido AR coating. Interestingly enough, I had to polywatch/dremel the outer AR coating off my Mido All Dial last year as it was splotchy and driving me crazy.
I don't know why any OEM would put AR on the outside of the crystal, that's just a problem waiting to happen. The good news I was able to get the AR off the outside using the combo very carefully not to heat up the crystal. Now it looks awesome once again.
Let us know your thoughts after you've worn it a bit.
 
#4 ·
I came to the thread hoping for pic and was disappointed :cry:

To your point on the Mido AR coating. Interestingly enough, I had to polywatch/dremel the outer AR coating off my Mido All Dial last year as it was splotchy and driving me crazy.
I don't know why any OEM would put AR on the outside of the crystal, that's just a problem waiting to happen. The good news I was able to get the AR off the outside using the combo very carefully not to heat up the crystal. Now it looks awesome once again.
Let us know your thoughts after you've worn it a bit.
The crystal can almost disappear with AR on the inside and the outside. My Sinn 556 accumulated a few micro scratches on the outer layer but I felt like I could reach in and grab the hands it was so clear.
 
#5 ·
my first gen Planet Ocean had a double AR coat i think. it was gorgeous. yeah eventually i got scratches but the crystal was sooo clear. it's clear again after getting it serviced a year ago.
 
#7 ·
Yes, scratches, scuffs and dings add character and add to story of the watch. If it really bothers you at a future date, and you still love the watch, just send it in for service and parts replacement, but I would think that watch will still look great years down the road...
 
#8 ·
Here’s a quick photo I snapped. Full review/photoshoot coming soon……
Image



I cannot describe how “nice” this watch looks and feels. Pictures absolutely do not do it justice. Even the bezel action clicks precisely and lines up perfectly

What I like most is how everything lines up and there are no apparent quality control issues. Coming from Seiko, I cannot describe how satisfying it is to have a watch that just feels so well-built.

This one is a keeper. Mido is a massively underrated brand. I still cannot believe I only paid $500 for this.
 
#11 ·
Congrats on your Mido. I've owned dozens of Breitlings (SuperOceans and Chronomat), Omegas (Planet Ocean), IWC (Big Pilot and Chrono 43) , Archimede (XLA and Deck) and Raymond Weil (Freelancer, Nabucco and Sport models), all with outside AR coating, and I have yet to see a scratch or spot on them. I don't baby them either, but wear them everyday.

I do use a soft microfiber rag to wipe them from time to time.

As long as you don't use the Mido to sand down steel, I think you will be OK.

Hope this helps.
 
#13 ·
If you are legitimately worried about scratching it up, then it doesn’t sound like a good beater option.

but you found a gem of a watch, paid more than a fair price for it, and it brings joy to you when wearing it becAuse its so nice. Id wear it like you planned to when you had the Seiko and just be really thrilled that even your beater brings you that much joy.

I just sold my beater (g shock) because it didn’t bring me any joy. It was useful and functional but I want the experience to be better.
 
#14 ·
It probably sounds crazy for someone outside the watch bubble but 500$ is next to nothing in the watch world. I bought a Tissot PRX 80 as a beater two weeks ago for 560€. It’s less than the service cost for the most luxury watches. Wear it. Go crazy. If it looks **** in a year or two buy a new one.
 
#16 ·
It probably sounds crazy for someone outside the watch bubble but 500$ is next to nothing in the watch world. I bought a Tissot PRX 80 as a beater two weeks ago for 560€. It’s less than the service cost for the most luxury watches. Wear it. Go crazy. If it looks **** in a year or two buy a new one.
It's not "next to nothing" for everyone. Let's have a little compassion for those of us who are more fiscally challenged. :oops:
 
#17 ·
I will say this. Probably an unpopular opinion. If this is a beater watch.....it's a beater watch. It should be worn because if will get "beat up" as the name suggests, and you shouldn't feel too bad about it. If you can't feel that way, it's not a beater, and you should really get a real beater watch for that purpose.

I think a true beater watch gains character as you nick it, scratch it, ding it, etc.
 
#19 ·
Maybe it won’t be a beater on the level of abuse my Seiko saw. Maybe I won’t throw it in a drawer or wear it on the beach. Who knows. But it’ll start out as an all-purpose “go-anywhere” watch and will probably become more of a beater as I become more comfortable with it 🤣🤣

This is the problem I have buying watches. I search and hunt and agonize for years over which one I want for a particular purpose. And then when I finally buy something and am satisfied with it, I become so attached to it im afraid to wear it lmao

The price and specs of this watch, it should really be a beater. But I just like it so damn much lol
 
#21 ·
Just to make the point clear I like posting these photos of my Tudor Heritage Ranger. It was purchased brand-new from an AD when it was first introduced in 2014, and I wore it doing anything.
For what it's worth, there's no AR coating on the sapphire crystal, but I managed to put a scratch on it anyways. That should put your "AR coating issue" into perspective? 😉

Like I said before, it's a watch.
Image

Image

Image

Image

Image
 
#24 ·
The crystal can almost disappear with AR on the inside and the outside. My Sinn 556 accumulated a few micro scratches on the outer layer but I felt like I could reach in and grab the hands it was so clear.
Yah, Sinn and Damasko do it right.

Odd that some people don't known if they have it or not. if your crystal reflects white light back with a bluish tint, you have it. If it is white, you don't (on the outside at least). Its harder to tell on the underside unless there is a different curvature to it.
 
#29 ·
On some TV show, there was a gentleman that rode dirt bikes. They recently built a decked out, pristine motorcycle. There was nothing left untouched.

Absolutely beautiful bike. To prepare it for it's very first time being rode. The rider pushes the bike off the tallest burm. The bike flops end over end. All kind of scratches.

The last thing the rider said before taking off on it. "Now I can enjoy riding it".

In other words. Once it's scratched. You won't have the stress of trying to keep it perfect. Acting like you're going to live forever and that watch will somehow stay the same.
 
#30 ·
Don't worry. I have an ocean star GMT since last October (double AR, Ceramic bezel), and I'm yet to see ding or scratch on it, given that I don't baby it. I make sure to clean it with a cleaning cloth I have for my watches and that's basically it.
Image

Beautiful and clear
 
#32 ·
Great-looking watch. I think the moderately-priced Swiss watches, particularly grey market, offer outstanding value.

Aluminum bezel inserts are pretty durable, depending of course on how much abuse they absorb and how much common sense you exercise. I wore a pair of dive watches for 15 years, and the aluminum inserts had a stray mark or two - that’s it. I wear a Certina dive watch, also has an aluminum insert & is a sister company, and it’s in excellent shape after a few years. If i anticipate situations where a watch might get hammered, i either wear work gloves with a gauntlet that covers the watch or wear a $50 Casio like a g shock or a duro (MDV-106, analog dive-style).

Image
 
#40 ·
Great-looking watch. I think the moderately-priced Swiss watches, particularly grey market, offer outstanding value.

Aluminum bezel inserts are pretty durable, depending of course on how much abuse they absorb and how much common sense you exercise. I wore a pair of dive watches for 15 years, and the aluminum inserts had a stray mark or two - that’s it. I wear a Certina dive watch, also has an aluminum insert & is a sister company, and it’s in excellent shape after a few years. If i anticipate situations where a watch might get hammered, i either wear work gloves with a gauntlet that covers the watch or wear a $50 Casio like a g shock or a duro (MDV-106, analog dive-style).

View attachment 16410287

The nice thing on this Mido deal was that it was from an AD with a two year Mido factory warranty not a grey market deal.(y)