WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner
1 - 9 of 9 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
155 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
Been on a affordables consumption bender lately and jumped on the Lobinni sale at Aliexpress a few weeks ago. It's maybe been mentioned at random on occasion here and a few were wondering what the quality is like (albeit months/years ago).

This Calatrava "homage" (re-cased from possible replica Patek Calatrava cases) offers the SL3000/ST21 (Liaoning Peacock or Sea-gull based 2824) for about $150 USD shipped. Not a bad deal.

Quite a nice dial although I suspect the seller sent me the wrong dial but I can't be sure since the available real photographs do not show the brown/cream dial. Overall the applied markers and hands are surprisingly decent for $150 watch with a Chinese 2824 version which are known to be quite a solid automatic and relatively cleanly assembled according to Lysanderxiii's many tear down reviews.

Everything lines up well enough and front and back crystals installed neatly and no one side sticking out slightly. Water resistance claimed to be 50m and I've run it through the tap and let it sit in a sink of water. No condensation visible inside even after heating front and back surfaces up so 50m claim seems to hold on the one I received. Looked through the entire watch with a loupe and was surprised at how well the printing is done. Maybe all this is really easy stuff nowadays. In fact the case work is rather brilliant but on the thin and flimsy feeling side. It is a slim and petite watch (not by dress watch standards though) at roughly 38.5mm diameter, 9mm thick without accounting for domed crystal and about 12mm accounting for the dome. If they avoided the cheap plastic movement holder and used a dense metallic one instead, I think this watch would feel more substantial and higher quality. It could use the extra weight but I understand many will prefer it light and comfy, which it truly is on a nice strap. The strap it came on is better quality than the usual business but the deployment is one of those butterfly type stuff that bulks up the clasp side - not a personal favourite.

Crown signed with a "Lobinni" L motif embossed pretty nicely. Feels light and cheap though with the usual ST21 action. Front crystal sapphire and back is mineral. Loveliest aspect of this watch is the design, thanks to Patek but how many are insane/wealthy enough to blow over $30K USD on a wristwatch :roll: (I'll take 100 various watches instead thanks :-d). The movement and price are rather appealing too.

I'll let some pictures do the rest of the talking.
 

Attachments

· Registered
Joined
·
28,467 Posts
Very nice |>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Paddy V

· Registered
Joined
·
262 Posts
This is one of their newest releases. A great looking watch with solid specs at a very reasonable price. I've had my eye on it for a couple weeks and have been thinking about pulling the trigger. They also have a version with a Sellits movement but it's around $400.
I currently own their 36mm model which I've been thinking about selling to make room for something else, but during the time I've had it I've have been thoroughly satisfied with it (only 1-2 seconds fast a day). I don't know if they regulate these things coming out of the factory but they somehow seem to keep excellent time. Surprising that the brand doesn't get a little more coverage from the whole Youtube community. I saw Jody from the JOMW channel mention one of their watches in one of his lists, so it might be starting to catch on.
In any case, great looking watch Enjoy it!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
155 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
This is one of their newest releases. A great looking watch with solid specs at a very reasonable price. I've had my eye on it for a couple weeks and have been thinking about pulling the trigger. They also have a version with a Sellits movement but it's around $400.
I currently own their 36mm model which I've been thinking about selling to make room for something else, but during the time I've had it I've have been thoroughly satisfied with it (only 1-2 seconds fast a day). I don't know if they regulate these things coming out of the factory but they somehow seem to keep excellent time. Surprising that the brand doesn't get a little more coverage from the whole Youtube community. I saw Jody from the JOMW channel mention one of their watches in one of his lists, so it might be starting to catch on.
In any case, great looking watch Enjoy it!
Yeah I saw the San Martin branded version of this Calatrava look (let's face it it's pretty much a direct replica sans hunter caseback) that are going for arond $300 to $400 usd depending on whether you opt for a Chinese 2824 or a Swiss Sellita 2824. The Lobinni is MUCH better value at about $150 usd still and I bought another one in a different colour dial. I'm quite certain the movement is a Sea-gull ST21 based on comparing it with a loupe with some other ST21s I have. Based on online breakdowns and photos of the Peacock SL3000, I don't think it is that one. So yeah Lobinni is using the ST21 here it seems which the seller confirmed to me.

Accuracy seems to be ranging between +2s to +5s per day so that should settle over time to something near perfect. If only they had a proper branding name, stopped pretending to be Swiss, and used a metal movement holder. Getting a cased ST21 in that lovely Calatrava shape and dimensions for $150 beats just about everything on offer. But these days everyone seems to be all about the sports watches.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
155 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
@Paddy V Nice review! Did you end up with the ivory/cream dial? If so how does it look?
Hi Theologian,

I bought one in the white dial and one in black dial. The cases are actually slightly different but both are of that scalloped (read Calatrava) style and I prefer the case of the black dial watch (same model) but the overall look of the white dial watch.

I didn't buy the ivory/cream coloured dial. Some online say it looks different in person compared to the photos. In any case, it is an absolute, absolute bargain for a ST-21 with a fairly decent execution of everything else. Can barely buy the movement for that price... back a few years ago that is.
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top