WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner
1 - 20 of 35 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I recently picked up a replica (if that is what you want to call it) of a NASA Speedmaster velcro watch strap and wanted to give my impressions of it, and show some pictures. So let's begin:

Here is a link to the item I bought:

Short NASA Velcro Watch Strap for Omega Speedmaster "Moonwatch" | eBay

I opted for the "short" version, because it was more practical, though not accurate to the original watch strap. There is a full length version also for sale here:

Long NASA Velcro Watchband Strap for Omega Speedmaster "Moonwatch" | eBay

I saw this item on Ebay and decided to give it a shot. Though the price seemed a little steep at around $50 USD (about 31 GBP, since it is from the UK) it seemed like a nice watch strap of decent quality to make the Speedmaster a little more fun to wear. It took about a week and a half to get in, which is very good considering it had to go from the UK to the US to a Military Post Office and then back over to Germany to my APO box.

Here is a picture of what was in the package:



I am not familiar with the history of these watch straps (just that they were used by NASA astronauts on their Speedmasters for the Gemini and Apollo missions) but the red and white sticker is a fairly nice touch I thought. It seems to be nothing more than a "NASA" approval seal with date and serial number for the watch band. I don't know if NASA ever used any sort of seal such as this for their watch band packaging, but it is a nice gimmick to make the watch band seem more "authentic" nonetheless.



The PayPal receipt in the above picture shows a message from the seller basically stating that first use will likely cause some of the loop fabric to detach and come apart, but that it will "stabilize" and can be trimmed with scissors to tidy the watch strap up.

After a couple days of wearing, I am very pleased with how the watch strap fits my wrist. It is very comfortable, and quality seems to be on par with what I would expect. Only time will tell if the hook and loop fabric will hold up, but it seems like good quality. In an effort to keep the watch strap nice, I would refrain from getting it wet, but I wouldn't see any issue with this if you did.

Here are a couple pictures of the watch strap and my Omega Speedmaster. The pictures show the band being installed on the watch by sticking the band straight through the spring bars with the watch strap sitting underneath the case back. I did not in fact keep it like this, as I did not want to take a chance of marring or scratching the case back as it is a signature feature of these Speedmasters (see pic below). I ended up looping the strap through one of the spring bars, then running it through the "D ring" and then running the loose end of the strap through the other spring bar, and folding it back on itself to strap it to my wrist. That might not have made sense, so if anyone want's a picture of what I mean, I can take one. Point is, it is a much better way to mount the strap I think, as it leaves the case back open to view, and also keeps it from getting scratched or damaged

Picture of the Speedmaster case back:


A before picture of my Speedmaster with it's original band:


Watch band layed out on table:


Period accurate stamping on band showing part number and serial number:


D ring:


A couple of wrist shots:



Watch with band layed out on table:


So, all in all, I am satisfied with the product. Again, I do not know much of the history with these watch straps, so I cannot comment on how accurate they are, but IMHO from what I have seen of pictures of the real thing (see below link for auction of Jack Swigert's flown strap) and read online, they are close enough. Obviously the real straps were longer (which can be purchased in the EBay ad at the beginning of this review) but I felt that it wasn't necessary and would make the watch uncomfortable to wear. The "shortened" version is good enough for me. Most people that wear a Speedmaster wear one due to their love of the NASA space program. It's the original "Moon watch", and wearing the same make and model watch as the astronauts wore on the Moon makes people feel a sort of special attachment to the NASA space program. This watch strap just goes the extra step and gives the wearer a similar sense of pride in their time piece.

Lot Detail - Apollo 13 Flown Instrument Cover & Omega Velcro Watch Strap From Jack Swigert's Estate
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,069 Posts
I have the same strap and enjoy the look and feel of it. While there are other "NASA Style" straps out there I think the straps Kizzi makes is the most accurate reproduction of the actual straps used my NASA during the Gemini and Apollo era. I know there have been a few treads over in the space collector forum discussing how accurately he has reproduced the strap. Enjoy!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
12,775 Posts
I didn't look at the ebay listing but that looks like a real NASA bond sticker on the package. To me, it looks like it's either gov't surplus, or stolen. :) Probably surplus.

Was it sold as a replica? Because it looks real to me.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
249 Posts
I have one of these as well. I had PM'ed Phil directly (a.k.a. Kizzy here on WUS) and we had some email correspondence before/after the sale and delivery. I agree the quality is very nice and the spec is as close to the real thing without actually having the real thing and Phil is wonderful to work with. I also purchased the shorter version and am very pleased. I loop mine slightly differently than you do. I first put the strap through the top springbar, then through the "D" ring, then around to the bottom lug, and back around to velcro together. Whereas it looks like you loop through both springbars before going through the strap ring. I don't have any of the strap touching the case back.

Good post!

EDIT: The sticker on the package is a replica. Phil told me it's just a little touch he added to make an otherwise plain plastic bag more appealing.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
12,775 Posts
I have one of these as well. I had PM'ed Phil directly (a.k.a. Kizzy here on WUS) and we had some email correspondence before/after the sale and delivery. I agree the quality is very nice and the spec is as close to the real thing without actually having the real thing and Phil is wonderful to work with. I also purchased the shorter version and am very pleased. I loop mine slightly differently than you do. I first put the strap through the top springbar, then through the "D" ring, then around to the bottom lug, and back around to velcro together. Whereas it looks like you loop through both springbars before going through the strap ring. I don't have any of the strap touching the case back.

Good post!

EDIT: The sticker on the package is a replica. Phil told me it's just a little touch he added to make an otherwise plain plastic bag more appealing.
Dang, that's a nice touch! I haven't really considered a velcro strap for mine as I just wear it on the bracelet, but he's done a nice job with what would normally be a boring piece of velcro. Almost makes me want one.

Thanks for clarifying for me.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,451 Posts
I have one coming that will look sharp on my 1976 Moonwatch.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
94 Posts
Thanks so much for sharing these watch straps here. If I may, I will add some extra information you might find useful.

The Velcro is about 40 years old, ex-Defense Logistics stock. That's quite old, and in my opinion the Velcro you get now in 2015 is much much better (like the ones with the latest mil-spec loop tape). I found a small proportion of the pile did pull away over time, making it look much more fuzzy, but the majority was pretty well woven in, so you can safely reduce the extra fuzziness without compromising peel strength of the hooks. The material is quite fragile for stitching. The binding tape is actually essential for the construction, and for robustness - these Olive Drab parts weren't meant for styling!

Any type of printing on Nylon will abrade eventually, and for these types it is just a regular typewriter with ribbon ink. I don't think it was ever intended to be permanent. The part number was to control what was brought into the spacecraft before launch, and the serial number was used for performance discrepancy reporting on return. If it lasted that long, it was enough. E.g. for Apollo 11 and See page 57: http://www.hq.nasa.gov/alsj/a11/A11CSD.pdf

I actually had to fight against the temptation of fixing any of these drawbacks, because I was not trying to produce a "good" watch strap, but just a realistic one like would have been used during Apollo.

The one thing that is over-engineered is the steel ring. It's 302 stainless steel, the hardest grade there is because of the proportion of carbon, and I need a special contraption to bend it. It won't scratch (except with a file, and only just) or tarnish. Softer 316 is an allowed alternative (as used for watch cases) but because of the chromium I didn't want it to look like the nickel plated rings.

I'd wash it often under a running tap (faucet?) with just hand soap, and dry it with a paper towel. Best to think of it like a Persian rug: the more used it looks, the more appealing it becomes, especially if then looks like it was made in the 1970s.

Phil
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,922 Posts
I thought about getting a NASA style strap before I even had a speedy in hand. But now that I have one I'm afraid of what the wear and tear will look like on the caseback. I think that the caseback is one of the best features of the piece and hate to cover it up. Any one have issues with excessive scratches or wear on their case?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,069 Posts
I thought about getting a NASA style strap before I even had a speedy in hand. But now that I have one I'm afraid of what the wear and tear will look like on the caseback. I think that the caseback is one of the best features of the piece and hate to cover it up. Any one have issues with excessive scratches or wear on their case?
I do not have the Velcro strap on my Speedy right now so I can't show you a picture but the way I have my strap on the watch the case back is not covered by the strap thus no rubbing or damage.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,451 Posts
I thought about getting a NASA style strap before I even had a speedy in hand. But now that I have one I'm afraid of what the wear and tear will look like on the caseback. I think that the caseback is one of the best features of the piece and hate to cover it up. Any one have issues with excessive scratches or wear on their case?
Just put a sticker or piece of tape on the caseback.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,451 Posts
I do not have the Velcro strap on my Speedy right now so I can't show you a picture but the way I have my strap on the watch the case back is not covered by the strap thus no rubbing or damage.
I think I know how you did it - you put the strap through one spring bar and then go back 180 degrees thru the loop hole of the strap so it hangs onto the spring bar with one end like a leash, then you go thru the other spring bar and swing back 180 degrees to attach the velcro to the strap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: flyinghell34

· Registered
Joined
·
1,080 Posts
Thats the way I wear mine too. I dont really like to have the strap under the watch as for me it feels like it increases the height and I dont like the way that feels.

Case back wear isnt an issue for me as I'm using a sapphire case back on the 321 Speedy and the original case back is in safe keeping, plus I get to see the beautiful movement everyday when I put the watch on and take it off :-d
 

· Registered
Joined
·
94 Posts
I thought about getting a NASA style strap before I even had a speedy in hand. But now that I have one I'm afraid of what the wear and tear will look like on the caseback. I think that the caseback is one of the best features of the piece and hate to cover it up. Any one have issues with excessive scratches or wear on their case?
Try it this way?

 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,451 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
2,922 Posts
Thanks for this pic. I was trying to conceptualize what this looked like and was having some trouble. With this idea I'm definitely going to get a NASA strap. I looked at the seller described on the first page but there weren't any straps available. Any other recommended sellers of accurate NASA straps?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,080 Posts
Thanks for this pic. I was trying to conceptualize what this looked like and was having some trouble. With this idea I'm definitely going to get a NASA strap. I looked at the seller described on the first page but there weren't any straps available. Any other recommended sellers of accurate NASA straps?
You can PM Kizzi directly as he sometimes has others available. I ordered mine directly from him :-!
 
1 - 20 of 35 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top