WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner

1 - 14 of 14 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,139 Posts
Discussion Starter #1 (Edited)
Just picked up a new to me Seamaster Pro and I have a Speedy Pro, thinking of selling the latter and getting the NEDU, blue dial, which I have always loved.

The Speedy fits like a glove and so does the NEDU, even though it's thick, it curves right around my wrist.

Why am I even thinking of this? The Speedy is delicate...hesalite crystal and not much WR, and all of my watches see boats, beach and water quite a bit, so it relegates the Speedy to nights on the town and casual gatherings, not much of a sport watch....right?

Tell me I'm crazy for thinking of selling the Speedy, an iconic watch, for the Ball. I know the Ball is every bit the quality of the Omega, I've had several Ball watches, but I am without one now and I miss the tritium and ruggedness and want one in my collection....and the NEDU has been at the top of my Ball watch wish list for a while. Also, note, that i am, other than Seiko, a one watch per brand guy...and now that there will be two Omega's in the stable...hmmm.

Sure, I can sell the Speedy for more than I will pay for the Ball, but that's not the point....what would you do?

Please note that it is not an option to have both as I want just one chronograph in the collection, other than "affordables".

Thank you for your replies!

Speedy 2.jpg Ball Nedu.jpg
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
111 Posts
If it was me...

Keep the speedy - for the heritage and sheer coolness (I love handwound watches so a bit biased here). The Ball is also a great watch, but you say you already have other watches doing the duty of water, boats and beaches.

I love Ball watches and in terms of quality vs price they are hard to beat, but that said; If you want to go Ball I wont suggest buying one retail anytime soon. If you can find the NEDU for a steep discount maybe consider it - especially if you can save a chunk of change from the sale of the speedy.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,457 Posts
No, the Speedy is not all that special really. If you're thinking the way you are, then it just means the Speedy's "icon" charm has worn off on you (somewhat at least; not necessarily completely), and that's perfectly fine. Get something you'll naturally enjoy, not something that doesn't suit your lifestyle but you feel you "should" enjoy because of its reputation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wschofield3

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,920 Posts
The Speedy is, I think, the single-most over-hyped watch here on WUS, and I just don't get why. Yes, it IS a nice looking watch, but it does have its shortcomings--depending on the model, it may be a hand-winder, the crystal may scratch easily, it has a tachymetre "function" that just about no one uses or needs, as well as a chrono complication that not everyone needs, can be very costly to service and/or repair, and so forth. On the other hand, it does look nice, runs fine, does what it is supposed to do. I think some people buy it just because they have been swayed by the hype, and didn't buy it because they were 100% "into" it. For me, I buy a watch pretty much to satisfy my own needs and interests, often ignoring what others think about the watch I'm considering. Whether the NEDU is a good replacement or not, that, I can't answer--I do have one chronograph, the Ball Cannonball, and I love it, and I basically have zero need for a chrono--go figure. good luck!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,299 Posts
The Speedy is both wonderful and overrated at the same time. I have one! Thing is, if you said you were building a watch collection and wanted a historical piece, then you most definitely need a Speedy. If you collection consists of watches you want to be able to wear on your terms, then I think you are right on about the Ball.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
29,051 Posts
The Speedy is, I think, the single-most over-hyped watch here on WUS/QUOTE]

+1.

Your watch, your decision, but I would go for the Ball in a heartbeat......
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,273 Posts
I too agree that the speedy is probably the most over-hyped watch, but there's no way I'd sell one to buy a Ball. Especially a hydrocarbon.

Let me ask you something. Did you try on the ball with the bracelet sized for you? You say you like how it curves around the wrist, but your wrist looks slim like mine and the top right lug will dig into the protruding wrist joint bone. I couldn't get rid of my ceramic xv fast enough after trying to live with it a few weeks. Lack of any bracelet adjustment made it all the worse.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,139 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
If it was me...

Keep the speedy - for the heritage and sheer coolness (I love handwound watches so a bit biased here). The Ball is also a great watch, but you say you already have other watches doing the duty of water, boats and beaches.

I love Ball watches and in terms of quality vs price they are hard to beat, but that said; If you want to go Ball I wont suggest buying one retail anytime soon. If you can find the NEDU for a steep discount maybe consider it - especially if you can save a chunk of change from the sale of the speedy.
Good points all around, thank you! Yes, I have others that do water duty and I'd never pay too much for the Ball, even though I think Ball shot themselves in the foot with their recent shenanigans.

No, the Speedy is not all that special really. If you're thinking the way you are, then it just means the Speedy's "icon" charm has worn off on you (somewhat at least; not necessarily completely), and that's perfectly fine. Get something you'll naturally enjoy, not something that doesn't suit your lifestyle but you feel you "should" enjoy because of its reputation.
Your last point is spot on, however, I really love the way the Speedy fits and looks, and those are primary driver for me, especially the fit part. It looks like I was born with it on. It's legible, which for my older eyes is good and if it were 100m WR, I would not be having this thought.

The Speedy is, I think, the single-most over-hyped watch here on WUS, and I just don't get why. Yes, it IS a nice looking watch, but it does have its shortcomings--depending on the model, it may be a hand-winder, the crystal may scratch easily, it has a tachymetre "function" that just about no one uses or needs, as well as a chrono complication that not everyone needs, can be very costly to service and/or repair, and so forth. On the other hand, it does look nice, runs fine, does what it is supposed to do. I think some people buy it just because they have been swayed by the hype, and didn't buy it because they were 100% "into" it. For me, I buy a watch pretty much to satisfy my own needs and interests, often ignoring what others think about the watch I'm considering. Whether the NEDU is a good replacement or not, that, I can't answer--I do have one chronograph, the Ball Cannonball, and I love it, and I basically have zero need for a chrono--go figure. good luck!
I agree with the shortcomings which is why I held off for so long, however, the legibility and perfect for me sizing won me over at the end, and I have an affinity for the space program. Conrad was right as I have a lot of "water watches', so at the end of the day, it's likely I'll just sit back and enjoy what I have for a bit, and if the Ball comes along at a great price meanwhile, I'll pick one up.



The Speedy is both wonderful and overrated at the same time. I have one! Thing is, if you said you were building a watch collection and wanted a historical piece, then you most definitely need a Speedy. If you collection consists of watches you want to be able to wear on your terms, then I think you are right on about the Ball.
Thanks, my thoughts pretty much exactly!

The Speedy is, I think, the single-most over-hyped watch here on WUS/QUOTE]

+1.

Your watch, your decision, but I would go for the Ball in a heartbeat......
The Speedy "over hyped" notion is a bit over stated as it is certainly a great watch within the criteria of legibility and size, for me, and as I said above, if it had WR at 100m or more, I would not be having this notion.

I too agree that the speedy is probably the most over-hyped watch, but there's no way I'd sell one to buy a Ball. Especially a hydrocarbon.

Let me ask you something. Did you try on the ball with the bracelet sized for you? You say you like how it curves around the wrist, but your wrist looks slim like mine and the top right lug will dig into the protruding wrist joint bone. I couldn't get rid of my ceramic xv fast enough after trying to live with it a few weeks. Lack of any bracelet adjustment made it all the worse.
Yes, I tried the NEDU on sized properly, it just happened to be perfectly sized at the AD. I've also owned the X-Lume twice and the Airborne for a short bit and all fit perfectly on my 7.25" wrist.

Thanks for all of the comments! Very much appreciated, but as mentioned, I think I'll just wait it out for a bit and see if a NEDU comes along at a good price somewhere and probably keep the Speedy for a special occasion watch.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
52 Posts
Good points all around, thank you! Yes, I have others that do water duty and I'd never pay too much for the Ball, even though I think Ball shot themselves in the foot with their recent shenanigans.



Your last point is spot on, however, I really love the way the Speedy fits and looks, and those are primary driver for me, especially the fit part. It looks like I was born with it on. It's legible, which for my older eyes is good and if it were 100m WR, I would not be having this thought.



I agree with the shortcomings which is why I held off for so long, however, the legibility and perfect for me sizing won me over at the end, and I have an affinity for the space program. Conrad was right as I have a lot of "water watches', so at the end of the day, it's likely I'll just sit back and enjoy what I have for a bit, and if the Ball comes along at a great price meanwhile, I'll pick one up.





Thanks, my thoughts pretty much exactly!

The Speedy "over hyped" notion is a bit over stated as it is certainly a great watch within the criteria of legibility and size, for me, and as I said above, if it had WR at 100m or more, I would not be having this notion.



Yes, I tried the NEDU on sized properly, it just happened to be perfectly sized at the AD. I've also owned the X-Lume twice and the Airborne for a short bit and all fit perfectly on my 7.25" wrist.

Thanks for all of the comments! Very much appreciated, but as mentioned, I think I'll just wait it out for a bit and see if a NEDU comes along at a good price somewhere and probably keep the Speedy for a special occasion watch.
Speedy overrated and owners trying to justify the price they paid. Been there following the crowd and now have the Airbourne and Nedu which I own.
Best fitting watch I have worn after 100 or so before them. Takes time but I think you know what I am saying. No point having a stupid collection and not wearing them "we all do it", takes time to find a stunner and you have just found two already !!!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
507 Posts
You're nuts. You seem to be finding fault with WR, but walking around on a boat or on the beach will not harm the Speedmaster.

To each his own though. It sounds like you have fallen out of love.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wschofield3

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,139 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
You're nuts. You seem to be finding fault with WR, but walking around on a boat or on the beach will not harm the Speedmaster.

To each his own though. It sounds like you have fallen out of love.
No, not fallen out of love, just that I find myself in and around water a lot and WR was always a big deal for me, but the way the Speedy fit and looked, it eventually won me over.

Now, I find myself reaching for other watches because most of my activity, during the warmer months, centers around the ocean, and during the day, I will be submerged in water frequently.

I've decided to keep it though as it really does look and fit great, so I'll reserve it for nights out on the town.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
630 Posts
I too agree, the Speedy is overrated!!

I buy watches I like! As I will be the one wearing them. I really don’t care about resale value, if I did I would only by Rolex and miss out on a hole world of watches.

If you feel the Ball calling you, go for it. If you don’t need to sell the Speedy keep it, as an ocasional special watch to wear every now and then. If you do need to sell it, you can buy it whenever... new or used, they are always available.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
44 Posts
If you are an active guy, the Ball will be more tolerant of knocks than the speedy. I also prefer an rotating timing bezel to the tachymeter. The Speedy is a classic, and great for dress wear, but I wear my Ball Trieste much more often than my Breitling.
 
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
Top