WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner

1 - 20 of 35 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #1 (Edited)
This is the second time I have posted a review on WUS so please bear with me on this. I am not particularly knowledgeable in the intricacies of the movements or the details of watchmaking, but I will post my every man comments as to what appeals to me in watches. For the record, I purchased this watch and the other watch in the review for myself, I did not receive a discount or special benefit on either of them, and I am not affiliated with either Serious Watches or Orient Watch company in any way. I am writing this review for others who may be interested in similar watches and because I am passionate about them.

To start with, some background, most of my watch collection consists of divers, desk divers, chronometers, and flight watches, essentially, I realized I needed a dress watch to round out the collection. The idea would be to purchase a few and then slowly cull the herd to around 10, I am still debating which to flip at this point. Enough on that. After looking around for a while I settled on Orient Star as the brand I was interested in. IMHO it represents both great style as well as excellent value. I appreciate that they make their own in house movements, that they are a subsidiary of Seiko (one of my favorite brands), and that they have their own history and direction. It started when I purchased an Orient Ray and realized what an excellent time piece it was, not to mention accurate. I was blown away, I did not expect that kind of quality at that price. So I perused for a couple months and ended up purchasing two Orient Stars, the Classic (in stainless), and the Classic Elegant (in Rose Gold Tone). For the record I am particularly attached to both but for differing reasons. I ordered both from SeriousWatches as they had them in stock (the Orient Star Classic Elegant does not appear to be available in the USA), came highly recommended, provided excellent customer service, and shipped from the Netherlands to Florida in two days free. For reference after exchange rate I paid around $425 for the Elegant, and $330 for the Classic.

I have included the Orient Star Classic in this review as I feel it is an appropriate foil for the Classic Elegant and allows for some contrast.

The design:

FullSizeRender (12).jpg

The Orient Star Classic Elegant watch has a very timeless design, to me it evokes an era before my time when a wrist watch distinguished you from the ordinary. It has clean and classic looks, the dial is a cream white, and from the outside in has painted on classic rail road style minute markers, a set of ribbed rings under the black painted on roman numerals, a date complication at the 3 O'Clock marker, and is followed by a textured center that includes a power reserve complication and black painted on orient star insignia with a rose gold flourish.

FullSizeRender (14).jpg

FullSizeRender (13).jpg

Overall the dial is, to my tastes, impeccable. It is legible, easy to read and elegant. It works with a casual pair of slacks and dress shirt, and I would be comfortable with it at a black tie event. If you look closely at the detail pictures above it appears that the paint on the numerals is in between the concentric ribs of the rings and that it has a lined appearance. I can tell you that is an optical illusion from the camera as to the best of my ability, even holding the watch right at eye level I cannot make out anything but sharp crisp lines on the numerals.

The watch has Breguet style watch hands that have are painted a dark but translucent blue. The color is interesting to look at and in some lights and contrasts appears black, but occasionally glints blue, which contrasts nicely with the rose gold tone case. The only complaint I have about the watch revolves around the hands in that the paint, if inspected closely (again look at the detail shots above) can appear plasticky and cheap, at least to my eye. I would have preferred a flat finish on the hands. I admit I am being nitpicky for a watch that costs less than $500.00, but I want people to know where the strengths and weaknesses are.

The crown on the watch is non-screwdown, coin edged, slightly diamond shaped, and is signed with the Orient Star Insignia. It is both simple and appealing in its design, neither standing out, nor an eyesore, it works well with the overall shape of the case. The top of the case is graced with a slightly curved anti-reflective coated Sapphire Crystal. It fits perfectly with the overall design of the case and really helps emphasize the elegance and finish of the watch. Both of which I find well designed and appealing.

FullSizeRender (8).jpg

The case itself is a polished rose gold tone stainless steel case. It measures approximately 38.7 mm in diameter without the crown and, IMHO is the perfect diameter for a dress watch, not so large that it appears gaudy on average sized wrists and not so small that it would be otherwise unnoticed. It is a little thick measuring in at 13.1 mm in depth, I would have preferred 11 or 12 mm, but again they can only do so much for under $500, and if I am honest it wears nicely on the wrist and has an appropriate amount of wrist presence. There is a nice cut ring around the case that adds to its elegance and draws the eye around it, keeping it from being plain and merely cylindrical. The lugs are, slender, drilled, 20mm wide, and taper nicely away from the watch, maintaining the very consistent dress appearance of the watch. The watch is rated to 5 ATMs, I imagine it could be splashed with water, but even without a leather strap, I would not wear this swimming.

My only real concern is how the rose gold color is achieved, if it is plated, how long will it last, and how will it wear? I hope that with proper care, and treating it as a dress watch should be, it lasts a long time because I plan on using this watch till it dies and cannot be revived. (EDIT, I believe it is PVD)

Orient made the decision to use a skeleton screw down case back that displays a nicely, but modestly decorated, 40N52 movement. This is the exact same movement that is in the Orient Star Classic.

FullSizeRender (6).jpg

The movement is a tried and true workhorse for Orient Star and to date (all three hours I have had it on my wrist) it has gained +0 seconds against the atomic clock at time.gov. The movement is a 22 jewel, 21600 bph movement, with a date indicator and power reserve meter, and a specified accuracy of +25 ~ -15 seconds per day. My experience in Orient Watches are they they are far more accurate than that. It is signed with the Orient Star logo adorned in yellow gold, and nicely, but modestly, polished for decoration. It appears to be exactly the same as my Orient Star Classic in every way, and I am OK with that, if it is not broken don't fix it.

It comes attached to a matte, dark reddish brown, alligator or crocodile embossed leather strap that measures 20 mm at the lugs and tapers to 16 mm at the buckle. The buckle is also rose gold tone and is etched with the words "OrientStar". It is clearly the weak link in the watch's design, but is perfectly acceptable at this price and more than usable while sourcing a new strap. My thoughts on it are that it is not thick enough at the lugs so the lugs peak out over the edge of the strap and it tapers too much for my tastes. To be honest I would prefer a 20/18 strap similar in sizing to the Classic, but I think that the 4 mm taper may be a classic dress watch style so we will see what I replace it with. It may be the first watch I spend a decent amount on a strap for.

FullSizeRender (4).jpg

FullSizeRender (5).jpg

The dark color of the strap compliments the rose gold perfectly. But as you can see in the second picture it has already started cracking around the buckle with only a couple hours of wear on it.

In my opinion, I am amazed at the quality and precision of this watch considering the price paid. $425 is still not cheap by any means, but I would gladly compare this to a $2000-3000 Swiss watch any day of the week. Of course only time will tell if it lasts and is durable, I cannot attest to that. But given my experience so far with Orient watches I am also not giving it any pause for concern. It is clean and classic in design, it has a very accurate and durable movement, it feels great on the wrist, and I expect it to steal weekdays away from the rest of my collection very very quickly. I would recommend it over almost everything else I have seen at this price point to anyone looking for a dress watch for formal functions, that can be dressed down when needed.

How it compares to the Orient Star Classic: (pure opinion)

The classic is exactly that, a retro styled, well built classic, a watch I can wear with any outfit that blends nicely, doesn't draw too much attention, but geeks me out with little details and build quality. However, even though they share the same movement and size, they are very different watches. The Classic is slightly slimmer, and due to its retro styled super domed crystal it sits lower on the wrist. It is dressy, but not a dress watch per se. The classic can pull of dress but it is more casual in looks. And last, even though they are similar it has a hardened mineral glass crystal, and considering how far out of the case it bulges could really use a sapphire crystal. Of course since they share the same innards the $95 difference in price is attributable to the sapphire crystal, and rose gold tone (maybe). Below are some shots that compare and contrast the two, you can make up your own mind...

FullSizeRender (2).jpg

FullSizeRender (1).jpg

FullSizeRender.jpg

FullSizeRender (9).jpg

FullSizeRender (11).jpg

I hope you enjoyed reading this review, and if you have any questions I will try to answer them. I really enjoyed putting these thoughts down for others.

Per the Sticky at the top, I have no objection to Orient adding this review to a database for their promotion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Nice review, fantastic watches, and great photos.
Much appreciated, it makes it worth it if someone enjoys it!

As a quick update the movement in this copy is at around +1/2 second on 4 hours right now. So I anticipate it will be around +4 seconds on the day. Well within the specifications.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
142 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Great review! I just ordered a Orient FET0T00250 Sun & Moon, and I'm looking forward to it, but a Orient Star Classic EL05005S is my next purchase.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #5 (Edited)
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Great review! I just ordered a Orient FET0T00250 Sun & Moon, and I'm looking forward to it, but a Orient Star Classic EL05005S is my next purchase.

Franz-Anton, I have always wanted a watch with Sun Moon, Moon Phase, or Tidal complication, I just think it is a cool complication to have. Congrats on it, I am sure like everything I have seen so far from Orient, it will be an excellent watch.

I love the Classic, if I did it over again I would probably get the EL05005S (I believe that is the two tone one), the gold embellishment would dress it up nicely from the pure silver stainless look.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
682 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Nice review and great watches,hope you enjoy them in good health.

The elegant classic is my fovorite but both are very nice.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
171 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Nice review and photos. Both are great watches for the money. You'll be happy with the OS Classic Elegant. I own the "non-elegant" OS Classic and it's also a fine watch, my only complaints are that the original strap felt stiff and cheap and that the crown ribs are a little too close to the case (the crown on the Elegant would seem to address that). Enjoy your OS Classic Elegant in good health!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #8 (Edited)
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Nice review and photos. Both are great watches for the money. You'll be happy with the OS Classic Elegant. I own the "non-elegant" OS Classic and it's also a fine watch, my only complaints are that the original strap felt stiff and cheap and that the crown ribs are a little too close to the case (the crown on the Elegant would seem to address that). Enjoy your OS Classic Elegant in good health!
Thanks, I am a little smitten right now with the classic elegant, but that might just be new face syndrome. The classic is an excellent piece and you really cannot go wrong with it, I am currently just torn between the two on a regular basis. I agree with the strap criticism, however, I can deal with the stiffness of the strap, it has worn in decently on mine. But I cannot deal with the buckle choice on the bottom... My main critique of the classic would include the buckle design (it is too clunky for the type of watch), and that the dial and hands can be a little illegible since I went with the stainless on stainless look (should have ordered two tone).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Great review!!! I've been wanting the Classic Elegant for quite some time now. I was about to pull the trigger, but read several comparisons stating that the build quality is not as good as the Seiko SARB line.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Thank you, I wish I could compare the two, I don't own a SARB line watch. So unfortunately I cannot help much with that comparison. I do know that I have wanted an alpinist for a while, however I just can't pull the trigger.

I consider this watch a pretty good value if you can pick it up for under $440. You are certainly paying a premium for some rather inexpensive but nice looking embellishments considering at the end of the day it has the same movement as the OS classic in it. The rest is just window dressing.

That said, it has been on my wrist non-stop since I bought it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Two small updates, it has officially been moved to an black matte alligator strap, which greatly improves the overall feel of the watch... See Below

FullSizeRender (2).jpg

FullSizeRender (3).jpg

The watch on the wrist gains 2 seconds per 12 hours, and off the wrist crown up loses 7 seconds... So averaging around -5 a day. No real complaint there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rfortson and GNNS

·
Registered
Joined
·
682 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

A very nice classic timepiece. :)
This strap goes well with it.

I am a fan of classic arabic numerals,but this one looks great with the roman,it has a traditional and elegant look.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

I would definitely pay the difference because of the sapphire glass and personally, I think the Classic Elegant looks much better than the Classic. There's something about dial that's just captivating on the Elegant.

BTW...the Alpinist is an amazing watch. I saw it when I was on vacation in Tokyo. It's extremely high quality. The 2 thing I don't like about it is that the strap is cheap (can be changed out easily) and that the compass feels a bit loose when you spin it. If there was more resistance to the compass, it would feel much more high quality. Overall, it's a great watch, nonetheless. Just giving my personal thoughts on the watch in case you're still interested in purchasing one. Things to consider.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #14 (Edited)
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

I would definitely pay the difference because of the sapphire glass and personally, I think the Classic Elegant looks much better than the Classic. There's something about dial that's just captivating on the Elegant.

BTW...the Alpinist is an amazing watch. I saw it when I was on vacation in Tokyo. It's extremely high quality. The 2 thing I don't like about it is that the strap is cheap (can be changed out easily) and that the compass feels a bit loose when you spin it. If there was more resistance to the compass, it would feel much more high quality. Overall, it's a great watch, nonetheless. Just giving my personal thoughts on the watch in case you're still interested in purchasing one. Things to consider.
I completely agree with the assessment of the Classic Elegant above... As my review stated the strap and the hands were my only real complaints. Mostly the hands look great but every now and then the light hits them just right and it looks like they used cheap plastic pieces. Still a steal of a watch.

As as far as your comment on the alpinist. I am alway interested and always looking for a deal. I am also impulsive. I have yet to see one in person, which is mostly why I don't have one yet. But if I find one for $300 I will pull the trigger so far the best I have found is around mid threes. In any event. I probably read the reviews on the alpinist once a month just for fun.

I know I have problems.

btw please pardon errors and grammar. Typing on iPad with dog and kid laying on each arm.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Good luck on your deal search for the Alpinist. I'm sure when you get it, you won't have any regrets. The entire SARB line is very high quality for it's price point. Actually, Seiko just make some of the best watches in all price points.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

I have to agree with that, Seiko is a favorite of mine, though I did harvest a couple of my watches to justify some new Orients. The SARB017 is next on my list of watches to pick up. But I will seriously have to wait because I impulsively bought around four Orients this month...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11,807 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Great review!!! I've been wanting the Classic Elegant for quite some time now. I was about to pull the trigger, but read several comparisons stating that the build quality is not as good as the Seiko SARB line.
I've owned 3 Orient Stars (Retrograde, Seeker and Classic) and 4 Seiko SARx (SARB017, SARB056, SARX001, and SARG015). To me, they are absolutely equivalent, and if I had to choose, I think I'd go Orient Star. Seiko just doesn't offer the complications like Orient Star does with power reserve, GMT, pointer dates, etc. That said, I love my SARx watches as well, and luckily don't have to choose between them (except every morning).

Build quality is the same for both watch lines.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #18
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

rforston

I saw your two tone Orient Star Classic and immediately drooled over it. I will have to pick up that at some point in the future. I have to admit I am pretty partial to the SARB017, but right now I am getting rid of watches from my collection so I cannot add more.

I am glad to hear a ringing endorsement for both brands and lines of watches...
 
  • Like
Reactions: rfortson

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,871 Posts
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Great review and a watch that I will definitely be adding to my collection. Nice clicks too.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #20
Re: Orient Star Classic Elegant - Rose Gold Case - SEL09001W - Short Term Review

Some new shoes arrived for my watch, and a new rose gold tone buckle... Back to Brown Alligator hide... The black gator has been moved to my Orient Star Classic.

FullSizeRender (2).jpg FullSizeRender (3).jpg

Loving this combination!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Franz-Anton
1 - 20 of 35 Posts
Top