I agree. Get both and keep the one you prefer. It's a tough battle. Could do either way. It's a mater of taste.Buy both of them. Wear them each for a week. Keep the one you like the best. Sell the other one to me at a discount.
Hope this helps!
--------------------------------
Killing Confusion By Eliminating Options
^^^This. The cartoony numerals are awful (re-issue or not) so rejected in a nano-second. The Zodiac OTOH is a joy to behold (date window notwithstanding), especially on a strap, and the recent price reduction makes this a no-brainer. May well get one myself......
Otherwise, it's a generic bezel, generic movement, simple handset, and aesthetics that looks like a toddler design it.