WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner
  • Take part in a short activity and share your valuable opinion on new design concepts for AVSForum! >>> Click Here

Tudor Black Bay owners please enter!

96722 Views 188 Replies 95 Participants Last post by  JasonKase
Hi,

I am interested in picking this watch but yet to see one in person.

Would anyone like to share their experiences of this watch? I am trying to order via a Rolex AD but would probably need to commit payment.

Wrist shots are welcome. Also anyone from London who owns this watch please let me know, would love to take a peek in person if possible!
21 - 40 of 189 Posts
Tried one on today at a Tourneau. Honestly, was a bit underwhelmed. I think the lighting was too dim in that store and it made the watch seem less vibrant (as far as the colors go) than the pictures online. Construction was rock solid but it felt thick on my admiringly small wrist. Still was one of the more interesting watches I saw in person though.
Didn't know Tourneau was AD for Tudors, gotta check 'em out, thx for the info1
Didn't know Tourneau was AD for Tudors, gotta check 'em out, thx for the info1
On Oahu, the only Tudor AD is the Ben Bridge at the Ala Moana Shopping Center.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
On Oahu, the only Tudor AD is the Ben Bridge at the Ala Moana Shopping Center.
Thx mleok! Interesting as the Tourneau site lists Tudor as a brand they carry but perhaps that's old info . . .
Thx mleok! Interesting as the Tourneau site lists Tudor as a brand they carry but perhaps that's old info . . .
Tourneau does carry Tudor in Orange County, California, but the brand is being rolled out in a limited fashion, on a store by store basis. So, for example, the Ben Bridge in San Diego doesn't carry Tudor, but the Royal Maui Jewelers does.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Tourneau does carry Tudor in Orange County, California, but the brand is being rolled out in a limited fashion, on a store by store basis. So, for example, the Ben Bridge in San Diego doesn't carry Tudor, but the Royal Maui Jewelers does.
Interesting, thx for the follow up mleok . . .
...but the brand is being rolled out in a limited fashion, on a store by store basis.
Yep, I've noticed that. My Black Bay came from an AD in Colorado, which is not my home state.
Tourneau does carry Tudor in Orange County, California, but the brand is being rolled out in a limited fashion, on a store by store basis. So, for example, the Ben Bridge in San Diego doesn't carry Tudor, but the Royal Maui Jewelers does.
Yeah. I tried it on at the OC one in South Coast Plaza. The sales person said that it was a new arrival/limited release from Europe (honestly thought it was just sales blabber, guess it was true).
Clarky, that bomber strap is a great match! Where did you find it? And what's your wrist size, by the way? I still haven't seen a BB in the flesh and am trying to get a perspective on the size/presence. Looks sharp on your wrist!
Apologies for the slow reply....

i got the strap from strappedfortime.com and my wrist is 7 1/4" and flat in top if that makes sense.
hope that helps.
Handled one at my local AD. If it was 300M with a ceramic bezel I would have been hooked. Left the store slightly disappointed.
I think i'm one of the few people who don't like this watch. I love the idea, the design, the colour scheme, just on the wrist, really dislike for some reason. I find the lugs too narrow, much prefer the fit and feel of the subC or 44mm watches that can hold their own. Pelagos and the blue monte would be my pics
Tried it on at my AD.

Looks -
The watch looks beautiful. Understated, elegant, classy yet sporty. They have really nailed the balance here. The highlights around the markers are just superb

Feel -
The small touches like beveled edges and ceramic balls in deployment are very neat. The clasp feels super solid.

A few notes -
I was dissapointed to find out that the watch does not have 904l steel and has 316l. Sure the benefits of 904 are not night and day and its just a technical thing for most, but coming from Rolex, since its made by them, I was assuming it would have 904.

Second, lume didnt seem that strong. Sure it wasnt ideal conditions, but I've seen better for sure

Last, there was absolutely no room on pricing whatsoever and IMO right now in the US, its quite high. I understand that Baume, Tag, Bell & Ross etc have comparable watches but on all of them you can get room with pricing and can get them for well under this price with very similar specs and build. To me, with the current strict pricing, its a no go. I'm going to wait and see what happens.
See less See more
Does anyone who owns one worry about the crown that sticks out with no protection at all?

It's a beautiful watch but I keep thinking I'd somehow knock the crown off within a month...
Does anyone who owns one worry about the crown that sticks out with no protection at all?
For diving I could see this as a concern, but otherwise it's just a like any other watch with no crown guard. It's not a very big crown in relation to other watches.
Handled one at my local AD. If it was 300M with a ceramic bezel I would have been hooked. Left the store slightly disappointed.
A ceramic bezel would have totally ruined the vintage vibe that is the raison d'etre for the Black Bay.

As for the water resistance, I would trust a 200M watch from Tudor long before a 300M watch from a lesser brand. How many Black Bay owners are professional divers who will even come close to testing the limits of the water resistance on their watch?
Tried it on at my AD.

Looks -
The watch looks beautiful. Understated, elegant, classy yet sporty. They have really nailed the balance here. The highlights around the markers are just superb

Feel -
The small touches like beveled edges and ceramic balls in deployment are very neat. The clasp feels super solid.

A few notes -
I was dissapointed to find out that the watch does not have 904l steel and has 316l. Sure the benefits of 904 are not night and day and its just a technical thing for most, but coming from Rolex, since its made by them, I was assuming it would have 904.

Second, lume didnt seem that strong. Sure it wasnt ideal conditions, but I've seen better for sure

Last, there was absolutely no room on pricing whatsoever and IMO right now in the US, its quite high. I understand that Baume, Tag, Bell & Ross etc have comparable watches but on all of them you can get room with pricing and can get them for well under this price with very similar specs and build. To me, with the current strict pricing, its a no go. I'm going to wait and see what happens.
904L steel is a hallmark of Rolex watches, and none of the Tudors use 904L.

In terms of pricing, the limited release in the US means that there is very little room to negotiate on prices at US ADs. I bought mine while I was in Europe, and through a combination of a favorable exchange rate, VAT refund, and a small discount, I got my Black Bay on a metal bracelet for $2800.
904L steel is a hallmark of Rolex watches, and none of the Tudors use 904L.

In terms of pricing, the limited release in the US means that there is very little room to negotiate on prices at US ADs. I bought mine while I was in Europe, and through a combination of a favorable exchange rate, VAT refund, and a small discount, I got my Black Bay on a metal bracelet for $2800.
Yes, that sounds about right, I think its good in that range. I was quoted $3700 OTD
Yes, that sounds about right, I think its good in that range. I was quoted $3700 OTD
At the $2800, it was an extraordinary deal. At $3700, one has options.
At the $2800, it was an extraordinary deal.
...especially on the bracelet.

While I prefer the aged-leather strap simply for the look, I think the clasp is much better feeling on the bracelet and definitely worth the money.
For diving I could see this as a concern, but otherwise it's just a like any other watch with no crown guard. It's not a very big crown in relation to other watches.
I've never understood the necessity of a crown guard for diving. It takes real, directed, effort to unscrew the crown. And if you're being subjected to impacts in that area of your body that would damage a crown - but for the crown guard - you've got WAY bigger problems than a flooded watch.
At the $2800, it was an extraordinary deal. At $3700, one has options.
You have options at $2800 too. You don't buy the Black Bay, or any watch, because it's a good deal. If you want one - for the unique aesthetic, and historical connotation, it brings, than neither $2800 nor $3700 is unreasonable. If you just want a quality dive watch, than both prices are too high.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
21 - 40 of 189 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top