WatchUSeek Watch Forums banner

Zodiac's STP 3-13 movement discontinued and irreparable

2 reading
8.6K views 23 replies 19 participants last post by  Dougabug  
#1 ·
Hi - I thought I'd post this in the interest of others who have a watch with this movement or really any Zodiac watch. I couldn't find any similar threads, but apologies if there have been.

I sent a Zodiac SSW 'Aquamarine Dream' for a repair quote to Fossil Australia. It was just a couple of months out of warranty and had stopped running. I'd already received a watchmaker's quote for $750-900 for a full service and potential parts replacement. I thought the email I received from Fossil was very revealing:

"Your watch style Z09283 is now a discontinued style for which parts are no longer available. Zodiac is a fashion brand of which styles are available whilst stocks last to be succeeded by later assortments. Whilst Zodiac ensures that parts remain available for after service, these too eventually become runout as is the case with your watch style. Whilst we are unable to repair your watch, we are offering you the option to trade in and re-purchase a replacement watch at discount."

Attached to the email was a catalogue of Zodiac watches from which I could choose a watch and apply a 50% discount. In effect, an equivalent type of watch would still set me back about AUD$1,300 with the discount. Aside from the personal aspect of this situation where the watch has died after basically 2 years, I was fairly astonished that the movement is completely obsolete from Fossil's point of view! I wouldn't expect Seiko to repair an NH series movement, just replace it. But the 3-13 was Zodiac's flagship COSC certified 'in-house' movement for a number of years. It doesn't leave me feeling positive about Zodiac and their approach to movement manufacturing and servicing, at least not in Australia.
 
#2 · (Edited)
There have been loads of issues with these movements so I’m not necessarily surprised to learn the line was discontinued.

IIRC the movement is a drop-in replacement for the equivalent ETA and Sellita. If this is the case, why not take the Zodiac to a local watchmaker and have them do a movement swap?
 
#3 ·
There have been loads of issues with these movements so I’m not necessarily surprised by the fact that the line was discontinued.

IIRC the movement is a drop-in replacement for the equivalent ETA and Sellita. If this is the case, why not take the Zodiac to a local watchmaker and have them do a movement swap?
Yeah, I've read about others doing that kind of swap. Sadly, being Australia that kind of stuff is almost universally very expensive. The only saving grace for me is that I didn't pay for the watch in the first place, so I've not experienced a financial hit in that regard. I really struggle with the idea of paying several hundred dollars for a service or replacement movement 🤷‍♂️
 
#6 ·
Interesting. I had my ZO9283 repaired by FG Service in the US when mine broke last year, which they did under warranty. They didn't say what they did for the repair, so it's possible that they just stuck a 1-11 in there and sent it back. The 3-13 was an absolute piece of hot, flaming garbage. Nobody outside of FG and Zodiac knows exactly what the failure rates were, but I would guess 20%+. There's a reason why they sh*t canned it after like two or three years of production.

FG Australia absolutely has 1-11s or 1-21s which they could easily swap in if they wanted to. They are ubiquitous and are used by a bunch of microbrands. You can also just buy them yourself on eBay.

I would under no circumstances pay anyone to repair a 3-13 that's already broken once. If you want to do it on the cheap, get a PT5000 or Seagull ST2130 and have somebody swap that. PT5000s and 2130s are both like $50.

The standard would be a Sellita SW200, or you could put a 1-11 in there if you wanted to. They both cost about the same. I'd go SW200 over 1-11, for the winding if nothing else. STP movements have the winding refinement of a cement mixer.

If my ZO9283 breaks again, it will be getting an LJP G100 swap. Those are about $250 instead of $180 for an SW200 or STP, but you are removing any possibility of the winding train issues that are inherent to the ETA-2824 and all of its various clones. The G100 is size compatible, but it's not an ETA clone. From my understanding, it's heavily based on Miyota's 9000 series movement architecture, and is a uni-directional winder like those are. You also get a huge jump in power reserve from the G100 vs. any of the ETA clones.
 
#7 ·
Interesting. I had my ZO9283 repaired by FG Service in the US when mine broke last year, which they did under warranty. They didn't say what they did for the repair, so it's possible that they just stuck a 1-11 in there and sent it back. The 3-13 was an absolute piece of hot, flaming garbage. Nobody outside of FG and Zodiac knows exactly what the failure rates were, but I would guess 20%+. There's a reason why they sh*t canned it after like two or three years of production.

FG Australia absolutely has 1-11s or 1-21s which they could easily swap in if they wanted to. They are ubiquitous and are used by a bunch of microbrands. You can also just buy them yourself on eBay.

I would under no circumstances pay anyone to repair a 3-13 that's already broken once. If you want to do it on the cheap, get a PT5000 or Seagull ST2130 and have somebody swap that. PT5000s and 2130s are both like $50.

The standard would be a Sellita SW200, or you could put a 1-11 in there if you wanted to. They both cost about the same. I'd go SW200 over 1-11, for the winding if nothing else. STP movements have the winding refinement of a cement mixer.

If my ZO9283 breaks again, it will be getting an LJP G100 swap. Those are about $250 instead of $180 for an SW200 or STP, but you are removing any possibility of the winding train issues that are inherent to the ETA-2824 and all of its various clones. The G100 is size compatible, but it's not an ETA clone. From my understanding, it's heavily based on Miyota's 9000 series movement architecture, and is a uni-directional winder like those are. You also get a huge jump in power reserve from the G100 vs. any of the ETA clones.
We'll see! Lots to think about - cheers.
 
#15 ·
I’m sorry that happened. The 3-13 was junk and a real hit to the Zodiac reputation. It’s unfortunate, because they have a lot of great designs, like the Olympos, the Super Sea Wolf, and they do an awesome job with colors. But, hard to recover from the 3-13 mess. I echo the idea of grabbing a replacement movement. Again, I’m sorry that happened. Total BS.
 
#17 ·
They couldn't just swap in a 1-11? That's pretty crap that they can't service a 2 year old watch.

Rumor has it the 3-13 is a Seagull ST2130 in disguise.

 
#18 ·
That seems like a Cop Out to a problem they caused selling defective movements. At 75% off, maybe I would consider it, but just maybe.

Have you reached out to Zodiac/ Fossil HQ versus Zodiac Australia to see if they would stand behind your 2 year old watch? Maybe they would offer you a better fix for what you have by replacing the movement with a functional option.

Otherwise, I would replace it with a Sellita or ETA equivalent and keep that watch going. Good luck getting it fixed.
 
#24 · (Edited)
I think the 3-13 was supposed to be a step up from the 1-11 as you say but turned out to be unreliable. The 1-11 is closer to the sw200. I'm sure others here will know more and will elaborate.

I've had a 1-11 for about 2 years now, on holidays, swimming, off roading, nights out, daily wearing, plenty of knocks, etc. and had no issues. Pretty solid from my individual experience.