I really really dig the Timex despite its comparative short comings.

 

I should say that it's $40 cheaper as the Q with the bracelet is $219. And the frog comes with a bracelet at $179.

 

Ribbit.

 

My preference would be the Timex Q Chrono and not the Tactical Frog Solar Chrono, which looks like a low-end watch.

 

Not all sapphires are created equal.
Tactical Frog is a trash tier homage brand.
Get the Casio. Timex

 

Not all sapphires are created equal.
Tactical Frog is a trash tier homage brand.
Get the Casio.

Which Casio?

 

I vote for the frog. Seiko movement, Raw Fuji Sapphire (whatever that is but likely a step above mineral), better bracelet and better lume than the Timex. Sure it looks like the watch named after a race track in Florida but the specs, at least on paper, look better.

 

The Timex looks great and I have never heard of it. Also maybe check out the Orient Neo solar as it can be had for around $150 on the bay

 

Timex.

 

Specs aside, the Timex is better looking

 

Thanks guys for your opinions, and Thank you @ronsetoe for the additional comparison watch!

So looking further into both watches I've discovered that the Q Timex has an Epson (Seiko) VS12a quartz movement with a 5 year battery, while the frog has an Seiko (Epson) VS75 Solar movement. I would guess that the quality of these two movements is probably even, one being solar and one being standard battery.

I was also curious where the Q Timex is made, and on the back it's made in China, just like the Frog.

So specs wise I would still say that they are almost even, but for me the Frog slightly wins. A couple of people have said that the Frog looks cheap, I don't agree, again for me, the frog wins on aesthetics as well.

And as for "homage" I would say they are both homage watches! Let's face it, the Originals are more than 10x the cost or more.

Keep it coming!

- Les

 

....
And as for "homage" I would say they are both homage watches! Let's face it, the Originals are more than 10x the cost or more.
...

The Timex Q Chronograph is a reissue of their 1970's quartz chronograph including its cushion style case, hidden lugs and the case's sharp angles. Being a reissue, it's an homage to that particular motorsport quartz chronograph from the past collection. Whereas the Tactical Frog Solar Chrono design characteristics look like a low-end watch resembling one of Seiko's recent re-issues.

 

For clarity, some pictures would be good but based on specs alone, I would go with the Tactical Frog.

 

Good point

 

Is the Tactical From a true three dial Chrono? It looks like one dial is a running 24 hour second time zone.

Edit: Just realized the Timex is the same.

 

I prefer the timex myself

 

I prefer the look of the Timex but it's 13.5 mm thickness would put me off buying it.

 

I'd bet 1mm of that is crystal dome. Which sounds erotic but isn't.

 

Good.

My advice remains go for the Timex, the watch is original, the brand has a pedigree with solid after sales, and the hobby is better off with brands and watches like Timex than it is with Tactical Frog. I am glad the poll endorses the Timex over that other… thing.

 

I appreciate your opinion. But the way I see it your dislike of the "other... thing" should create an equal dislike of the Timex. And in my opinion if you're going to hate on one brand because it comes from a particular country, you should hate (maybe a little more) on the other brand for shipping off it's manufacturing to that same country. And if it's a copy cat thing, then again the Timex is also a copy cat!

I respect Timex for bringing watches to the working class, I'm pretty sure my first watch as a kid in the late 60's early 70's was a Timex. I will be adding one to my collection at some point for that very reason. But it probably won't be this design. Probably a Marlin with Peanuts. That's the design that I think of when I think Timex.

 

IMO it’s fairly close but the Timex wins.

 

If I were choosing, it would be the Timex, no question.

Your poll is running almost 3-to-1 in favor of the Timex, but it sounds like you've already made up your mind.

 

I said so in my original post, but I think it's very close. Because of that I'm curious what others think. I'm not purchasing ASAP so I could change my mind.

 

Well, this thread caught my attention and now I want a Timex Q Panda, which I thought I would never say (or type) those words. Wonder if I can order the black rubber strap in addition for the white dial. I want to be Paul Newman driving my Jeep around town

 

I would pick TF over the Timex based on the case's lugs.

 

Damn! The reverse panda looks fantastic

Q Timex Chronograph 40mm Stainless Steel Bracelet Watch

Roar across the finish line with our high-performing Q Timex Chronograph. Inspired by the original motoring watches that graced the tracks of Europe’s most iconic races, this timepiece celebrates the endurance of our legendary 1970s Q Timex. An ultra-precise chronograph movement and black...

www.timex.com

 

Get Solar Gshock , Citizen AT2441-08X or for lil bit more Seiko Arnie

Sent from my SM-G781W using Tapatalk

 

I voted for Timex. Everything else aside, I could never wear a watch that says “Tactical Frog” on the dial. 🤣

 

Well, I purchased the Frog! It looks and feels great.

 

Well, I purchased the Frog! It looks and feels great. View attachment 17027221

By now , you'll probably have realized how accurate the movement is , is really mind boggling the quality put in these watches considering the asking price,
good choice...!

 

I think you made the right choice.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Congratulations! Nice looking watch